Town of Troy Budget Committee Meeting 6/9/2025
Speakers are labeled SPEAKER_N. This transcript is machine-generated.
Oh my goodness. You'd be good at it. Okay. All right. Okay. So, that's this. Would you want to serve too? All right. I'll continue just because it'll be good to be there too. Sidekick. Yeah. Well, yeah. I was part of the since left us. I was part of we usually meet at the town hall and try and do it opposite budget so that it's not Yeah. So you're gonna be on be on as well. Yes. That's good. Yeah. Because a little bit so that we'll have two budget and planning. Yeah. Well, that will help what we've talked about. I have notes. So all right. So that's the CIP. So as far as So that kind of ties into our goals as far as ensuring we're saving correctly for that. The other goal we tal Oh, sorry. Let me get back here. So, the other thing we talked about last meeting was department surpluses kind of having which would have to be warrant articles to say any department surpluses could roll into the CIP accounts or [Music] our capital capital funds. So, helps motivate departments to try and act fiscally responsible and that way it helps go towards their purchases. By act fiscally responsible, you mean spend less. Spend less, but really think about it. And then it actually benefits their programs in the long run. But rolling the fees over also encourages them to budget more. Well, yes, that's a that's a possibility. It's your job to say no. So, that's where I think we have to come in and say, so let's really look at your budget. what are you doing here? You know, we're not we're not going to increase budgets in the hope that it will roll into that. That's where I want to be clear with folks that we're really looking the town has spoken in our last meeting and I think we all agree to living in the town. We can't keep affording these increases constantly that we want to cut budgets. We don't we're not going to tolerate them continuously to grow and to feed these CIPs. We have to be smart with how we're managing our money to make sure we're getting our important things met and when we can find ways to support reductions that can go into purchasing the needed equipment in the future that is done appropriately and not extravagantly. It also suppresses the need to oh we got money left in our budget let's buy something. Well, that's the other thing is that yes, like you know how many whatever exactly that you're just not spending money to spend money that it's done frugally and appropriately. That could be done properly too is if you're going to buy something now money that would otherwise lapse and not put in next year's budget. But that's what I think John really should this year. I I would I would wholeheartedly disagree because I think if you if you budget properly and you have a solid And like if you got I have if he has culverts to do every you know every year and he's got I figure about 10 culverts a year what have you. Um that should be well budgeted. You shouldn't just shoot for the moon and then try to just figure out how to spend that money later on or towards the end. And and I get what you're saying. You have some extra in the budget. You can spend it now. It's not going to get any cheaper. But um I think if you got proper planning and you find some savings during the year, this is kind of the way to incentivize people to or department heads to get to the end of the year. And if you've got a gap in your budget, say you got 5% or whatever, there's no rush to spend it. You know, there's for the reason that you're talking about you, if you don't need to spend it, I mean, yeah, you're going to need those items next year anyway, but if you if you properly plan, it's going to be in your budget for next year. So if you just get to the end of the year, there isn't this rush to spend that last five or 10% which is which is potentially the case. Um then uh yeah, I think that's the incentive. It's really not the incentive to cut. It's the incentive to just not spend unnecessarily right at the end. I I think that's a a smarter way to do it. So let's look at the practical considerations here of putting them into putting it into the expendable trust. That's what we're talking about. So Jake Dick brought up the meeting and they briefly touched on it. They didn't go too much. Well, they didn't sound opposed to it, but logistically it might cover. Yeah. Because those are all town meeting expenditures, right? Y trust fun to to fund them. They are to fund them. Yeah. Well, depends. So, you have to have articles to put that money in. If if the agents to expend are the select board or somebody other than town meeting, then yes, you're correct. But if the agents to expend are town meeting, then um you have to have a warrant article to put in and a warrant article to take out. You need a warrant article to put in. Uh yeah, I was just saying you have to have war. We have to be able to get it out too, right? I I would have to say in regards to like with the leftover what's remaining it would be beneficial for department heads as well as for us for the budget committee like where last year we weren't asking for five months to have like things that were paid in June reflected in the budget and they weren't done till January of this year. So like the insuranceances things like that they weren't even put in the budget until January. So, like it looked like some of these departments had $100,000 plus in their account, but once all those were taken out, they didn't. They only had like maybe $40,000 left. That would be beneficial to actually have an accurate amount reflected. So, if like they these bills were paid in June, actually have them reflected in the in the budget instead of waiting till January to reflect that. That would actually be really beneficial for department head as well as us to see exactly what happened. So, I'm not understanding why what well like last year like Yeah. property insurance, liability insurance, vehicle insurance, none of that was taken out until January of this year in any of the budget the budget do. Yeah. And they were all paid in June, I think it was, but this year they've already been done. Yeah. And part of it was trying to figure out the actual cost for each each breakdown. Yeah. They found the numbers. Um, Primex will give you an allocation sheet. It basically spits out by how many vehicles you have and the cost of the I went through it like all these numbers are all out of whack whatever and it all depends on who before me calculated how or whatever so but she's done that already for this year which is good I asked about asked about the transfers from the trust and reserve funds yes that and those haven't been done yet because of cash flow which tax bills went up today by the way everybody the vice president will vote So, as you know, when it comes time for bills to go out, our cash gets pretty the schools send you invoices at $200,000 a whack, right? But that's a smart way to do it, right? Because if you don't have an impending expense coming out of that capital reserve as a result of town meeting or what have you, funding it from the town meeting vote, um, delaying that until you have the cash to do it and not getting a a tan is is definitely smart. Yeah, that's I like that. I didn't realize they had done that. So, those transfers which I'm assuming done pretty soon once we start paying what other expenses would have been. That's mostly it. Yeah, I think it was just those. Yeah, those good. Just a matter of me going through and calculating them all and say this the number we're going to the best. So the the plan here, the way I'm thinking it is is budget closes. You look at what's left and you're writing war articles to move that money. It'll be approved in town meeting. So you've got until town meeting basically to figure out the numbers. The numbers is there a cap on what can be put into it's all going to lapse the sign fund balance can use that to either pay down the tax or fun. Right. Right. And that's why we got to be in in absolute agreement with the select board on this process because if they take that unassigned fund balance and pay down the the tax rate with it um then there's no money to put in the capital reserve as as promised to the for the um department heads. So it's got to be which I' like to get away from anyway until so we can stop taking up 10. Y but I mean the unsigned fund balance is really imaginary number. If you don't have a cash flow there you don't have cash there. Well, and one of the things too is if we don't have our audits done, you can't spend that money. So, if you have if you have unassigned fund balance that hasn't been audited, you can't spend what's in there. So, you we're spending money from years ago and we're going to be catch caught up soon enough. So, everything will be on the same timeline. So, that should that should start to work out much better. We're hoping that online property tax payments will start to help the cash flow issue a bit. Speed up payments. Last year, we were really late on getting the tax rate set, so that pushed everything back. So we really get a good view at it. But we're hoping that with online it's the same thing if you pay down the tax rate or pay down a war the same day you are giving back. I think too the um this um you know the the surplus being transferred into the capital reserve is not going to be universal across the board. Right. Right. because like welfare department, they don't have any capital reserve. So that would just go back into the the general fund. Um the highway department actually has multiple capital reserves. So if they had $50,000 left over, um you probably working with the CIP, the department head and the select board deciding where does the 50 go? Does it go to those highways and streets? Does it go to to the highway department CRF? You know, one is for roads and streets, one is for equipment, you know, and how do you want to how do you want to do that? Um, so I think it's not going to be universal across the board, but it will definitely be in some of our bigger departments. It will be I think it will be generally helpful. I think it' be a pretty easy process to navigate between December 31st and uh and town meeting. Hopefully. I think a perfect one would be the reassessment. Take whatever's left over in the assessing budget every year. Yep. Right. Exactly. Yes. If you pay a ideally there won't be much in there anyway because we calculated it properly. Yep. But if you do have some, you put it into the reassessment plus whatever CIP is doing and it might offset CIP. If CIP is properly built and you have the right amount of money going into that fund for our 10-year assessment or our 5year assessment, wherever we're at, um, and you know that you're good with that, then the money going into you won't have to. So you won't have to fund it from the CIP. You'll just fund it from the surplus or just leave it alone. one or the other. So yeah, have choic. Yeah. No, it's their warrant. So if they're not on board then is all the warrants really. The whole thing with the TA is nice to not rely on those because Yeah. We're paying down the tax,000. But when you're taking out 40 grand, right? And I asked the auditors about that. They said towns are starting to use it less and less. And I said, how do we get to the One idea that came up recently I need to investigate is you know we have all this money like what I'm really thinking of right now is the grant funding from the state that's sitting there collecting making good interest like why can't a town why can't we borrow from ourselves for that cash flow because really the one issue we have every year is mid December when the county wants their half a million dollars that's what it is every year so why can't we just take part of that borrow from ourselves once the tax bills go out start getting money in put it right back So it's like a loan for we're sitting on millions of dollars in these accounts. Why can't we borrow from our symbol? Take it out. I need to ask. Yeah. Well, and I think the idea is you would just have enough in surplus to, you know, in the general fund to just handle it. So, so just so you know, Troy didn't start taking out tans religiously until probably 201 19, 2018, somewhere around there. Before that, Janet was like hardcore about dollar. Yep. And she and she was she I mean they what do they say like eight to 30% surplus or something like that is is the standard is a broad range. Five to seven, right? It's it's this wide range of what you might want to keep and it's 5 to 17 of the operating budget. So guideline too. Yeah. It's just a guideline. It's not a law or anything. So you can you can pay right right down to this 5% hanging around and then you need a tan because you don't have enough cash flow to pay the bills when the big bills come in because the taxes come in after the big bills come. So yeah, so I I think so just so you know, we were able to do it not not all that long ago. So but we also had you know cash hanging around and and I think Dick's thought process behind it was don't keep the taxpayers money. Um give it back to them. you know, don't hold on to it for the future. But if you're going to spend $50,000 in 10 interest because you gave it back to everybody, everybody's paying money anyway. Exactly. So, it kind of makes no sense, but the the other question I have is should we restrict the line item accounts to which ones go into their ETF? Limited limited to what they what things they can actually like why for what? What purpose would that serve? I think I think we're getting too much of the lead there. Well, I'm just curious. Just a thought. Like they can get money back if they don't buy so many band-aids, but they can't do it if they don't use the salt. I mean, which lines would Yeah, I'm thinking things that they have no control, you know, like maybe You're noting oil. So, they're not going to have money left over. It's not a pun, right? It's not a I mean, they may have money left over, but it doesn't go into the ETF. It goes into I think that's going to make a Warren article a real nightmare. I mean, writing think about that. I'm just No, I hear what you're saying, but like I feel like that that might be quite a bit in the weeds and then breaking that down might be challenging. You do want to have some surplus. Yeah. Right. Well, that's why I was asking is can you only do a percentage or basically you're basically shifting your surplus, right? And I I think I think when we start when we start grinding out the math on this, you're going to see that the surplus comes from a number of different places and and it may just work out on its own that there's enough surplus in whether it's welfare or places that don't need to be using the surplus or the CIP has got plenty to cover cover that and that surplus will stay in the fun. ly you don't have to get the tan but it all kind of has to be worked out mathematically to figure out you know you almost have to run one year through it to see it's not going to happen to all shuffle out the first year it might not you might look at it and go you know this doesn't really work let's do whatever is left of your budget where we're going to put 50% into your capital reserve funds and the other part has to go into the general fund because we need that to keep from buying keep from getting a tan so that makes sense but I think there's I think there's some meat on that bone regardless. I definitely wouldn't get granular within the budget as to, you know, what will what will go to where should there be any left over. I would I would do it more macro. Do it in percentages and first. They have to be on board. Well, right. Everybody else has to be on board. Yeah. These Yeah. This is just kind of like these are our thoughts that we're gonna share with the these these items that we do strictly so we can spend money that's going to be reimbursed. Yep. Like the revolving fun. Yeah. The revol revolving like police details. Police details. Transportation. That's a special. We have one We have one for the ZBA that covers postage but we get paid for postage. Right. So, you're saying like eliminate those? No, you have to have it. Yeah, because they're I think it would kind of come out in the wash. I mean, that's where we've always had the issue of connecting those with the budgets because you don't it's not always well, but but if you think about it, you put it in the budget and you spend it and it comes back. Yep. So, you haven't really spent it at the end of the year. Well, you you did though because we have to have it in there to spend it and then you could still have some leftover. I mean, that's not going to it's I don't think it's going to affect the end of the year the revenue comes in. Yeah. To cover what you spend the building, right? So, it's it's basically a a bookkeeping thing, right? There's no real the budget that we're working on here is appropriated for this, right? Yeah. And then there are different sources of income, tax money, fees, right? They cover them. Selling hot dogs and hamburgers at the rec center. Excuse me, the community center. Yeah, we don't even know where the story. But yeah, so right. I think you know we we appropriate, spend it, and then in some cases it's reimbured from other fees. just just throwing things out. I think what Steve's basically getting at is it's non um non- tax revenue, right? So, anything that is a fee revenue, um whether it's details for the police department or fees down at the dump or what have you, um those are all coming in that are offsetting the the associated expense. So instead of just straight from taxation, um I don't know if it's important to separate that out or not, but that's that's we should probably look at that. That's essentially what you're getting at. Yeah. See what what it adds up to. Yep. Is it more than what we have appropriated? Is that what you're saying? Well, you're right. No. No. Just see if it's even worth worrying about. Okay. You know, if it's if it's a big enough sum that hey, this is something that matters. Okay. Okay. Basically, every year you in theory you put the money in a budget, you tax based on a budget and then at the end of the year you never spend the money. Um, one of the things one of the things that you're basically asking for that we've been asking for for a very long time is to be able to see the revenue side lose that. Yeah. Yeah. And I think some place in our records we need to tag those line items that are have revenue behind just so we know because that was One of the things I had a hard time when we started out here was like we know in a roundabout way is that we just don't see it on the state the state budget form that has a revenue side. So it's all a guess right but you're putting in there what you anticipate taking inspector we would have you know some sort of number there saying take x for inspections. So when they do the formula to figure out your tax rate, how much money you need to raise from taxation, there is a number there whether it's accurate or not. Time tells most of the time, but there's no compensation in the figure out. So you're really not you're really not taxing the people for an account that you're also putting in a Okay, that makes sense. All right, that's cool. It's kind of like if you have the wrong number, yes, you are like say we you are setting the tax rate. You you hope you've accounted for all of that revenue that comes in. Yeah. Like Yeah. If we if we have a budget of 10 and we estimate 10 to offset it five $5,000 deficit that you know works it way out through the budget process. So I So but but if historical information too okay so so let's look at the post that you for so everything that goes into that the applicants paid for right okay so no matter if we use half of it it really doesn't matter because none of none of the other part went out. You know, if you if you if we use half, the other half never got touched, right? Nobody ever wrote wrote a check for it or, you know, spent any of it. So, there's no liability, you know? It doesn't mean that we ran a deficit. It's like the opposite, right? [Music] But but if you think about it throughout the year that's getting spent and reimbursed actually it's getting reimbured and spent. We don't spend it till we have the money from the applicants. So it's really like not doing anything. You set it pretty low and if it got updated properly it would work. Yeah. But the that's just not the way municipal budgeting works though, right? because you have to raise and appropriate the funds in order to spend it even though you have enough to offset it. It's a little bit like the um the police detail is the best example of it because it's basically literally every dollar we spend is covered by the money coming in, right? But you cannot spend it without raising and appropriating it at town meeting. So, um but you're it's all done it's all done bulk over the year. Yeah. And I and I think you're you're circling around the the point a little bit though is um in in those departments, you're not necessarily anything left over in the budget is um is not one of those budgets that we're looking at putting into capital reserve funds because they just don't have one. EBA doesn't have one. The special revenue fund shouldn't have one um for the police offset. Um so yeah, so that so I think what you're circling around there is is those are just the departments that we're not going to apply to this this program. Um, but as far as as we're still on goals here, one of the goals should be we can't answer a lot of the questions that you have until we see the revenue side. And if we were getting an active reporting from the revenue side, that should be one of our goals is to is to request and and start to receive that information on a regular basis is the revenue side. Why don't we? Well, some of it So, some of it comes in like for instance, um, and this is an Adam question actually, the treasurer. So, some of it comes in the way Janet used to do it. Let's use the transfer station as an example. The money would come into the transfer station. They would bring it up to the the town clerk's office, record the deposits and stuff for the month, and then they would go and deposit into the into the account. Yeah. Um, so and Janet would track all that on a spreadsheet. Yeah. So it's not like we have a point of sales system down there that's taking in the money and then making the deposit and we, you know, whether it's QuickBooks or something like that where we can just report out on this thing. So um, it's very manual to track that account and there's a number of those accounts. I don't know how many Adam has, but as far as revolving type funds, but there's a number of them. So that's part of it. Um, now the tax collection, that all happens through the tax collector's office and that's all in BMSI and that's reportable. You can she can print that off. I'm pretty sure she does all of her dog licensing and her marriage licensing and all that stuff right within BMSI and kind of yeah, excuse me. A little glitch, but um but anyway, so so it's not all in one one spot. I think that's the point. Jenna did really really good detail the spreadsheets and we just don't have that. Yes, exactly. And nobody really wants to put the time in to do all that which I get. And quite honestly, we should be building out those accounts even if they're just macro level in Avatar on the tax collector side. We really should like if there's money coming into the there should be an account for the uh the trans transfer station revolving fund. Yeah. And the money should come in there and and it should be recorded in Avatar. They're the next department to take cards. Yeah, I heard rumor because they handle sometimes thousands of dollars. I know. They bring it over to me. I go through it all and count it and put it in a spreadsheet and give Sarah, she counts it and deposit it. Yeah, there's just a lot of cash flow. I've talked to other towns that let their I know in yeah we've had we've had uh but if you go of fraud in this town so if you go to the dump on a Saturday back again right but we're paying a fee for that aren't we? What are we paying percentage to the user? Yeah the user will be paying the So they're so the the card owner the bag purchaser will be paying so you pay your water bills. So it doesn't and then the department itself will pay $50. I mean and that's everywhere. It just you know all right but you have the check option and you still have you know you can do money orders and all that stuff. I Yeah. It's old school by the people that that rely on cash they do it. You don't want to take Bitcoin? All right. Okay. All right. So, that's one step too far. Understanding the revenue side, I think, would help everybody in the town understand how and the whole I think education around the whole appropriation of funds and how it's important to be in the budget, but some of them have income sources that come in to cover it is right. That right that aren't right out of the taxpayers's pocket. Exactly. That I think is is helpful thing to understand. Now when we say like a regular basis, how often are we talking? Like for every meeting that we come have or like every other meeting? Sorry. For what? For like regular basis to get that report. Like are we talking every other meeting or like every meeting? If we were talking if we were asking for um that from from Janet, it would have been monthly. Monthly. Okay. Very easy to do a monthly report. So all right. Okay. Something that gets sent down if you guys aren't meeting. Yes. I think that would be really helpful to know. And then it'll also kind of see how the tracking of things. Yeah. You see the in and out of the month, right? When the busy times are there's lots of great detail. Well, you know what? Okay. We'll shoot for the stars and hit the moon, right? But in reality, I mean, even if you had the the month total deposit for and it was for this this account, that would be, you know, that' be something. So, we got to start somewhere. All right. We've got our CIP going. We've got a goal for revenue. Look towards the select and see if they are on board with it. They mentioned the 10% too. The 10% like the cut. They're not they're not totally convinced it's going to be a feasible. Well, you know what? Again, you know, Everyone everyone's trying to save money in life in general because nothing's getting cheaper. So it's not just personally, it's within the town as well and it all affects us personally. So this is a goal for everyone. I think if we go the right way and not have the way I don't think we go 10% and say you need to cut your budget 10%, but we need to help people look at their budgets and go okay let's let's look about this with a scalpel. Depending on how the health insurance plays up too that will help. I in order to cut cut the town budget 10% you need the elimin what the health insurance well I don't mean just that but I mean if you want if they make a significant change in that you know yeah want to talk about that that could be 5% these numbers are crazy for health insurance can we talk a little about this since it's in the packet are we are we Well, no. I think yes. It'd be interesting to talk about the numbers. I don't think we have information on it. Like I think that's the problem with the health insurance. These are the crazy numbers that But where are we as far as looking at other options that are less expensive? So what happened was currently in the state house um there were bills proposed to drastically go after risk pools and things were so bad that the health trusts executive committee got together and took a vote before the bill even went anywhere. said if it passes as is December 31st we're full on tr which would mean like 300 towns in school districts in the state have no insurance because right now there's New Hampshire health trust school care and there was a third party who's already done that and the unfortunate thing is when you talk to a lot of schools in towns they have blinders tunnel vision like you mention anything outside of the norm and these plans like they don't want to talk to you about it which is unfortunate got an email today from health trust and they you know it's like sausage here they amended the bill it's gone back and forth between the house and the senate and it sounds now that everything's all rosy they're all happy again so it sounds like they're not going anywhere but the selectman wanted to look into this regardless of the result of that if they had gone through and they were going away then we' have a choice us and 300 other towns would have to find another option but it sounds like survived but um the problem with our current insurance is that Yes, it's really, really good. There's no deductible. I pay $10 for prescription. I pay $20 to go to the doctor. A lot of our staff's young and deductible. You cut a check for $1,300 a month for my insurance. 85% town, 15% me. Whether I use it or not, they're cashing that check. Okay. So, the first question is these numbers is the total outlay for insurance. That's not the actual because some of that is revenue offset by the 15% that you're paying that's in there. Um so the third line down the total monthly cost the bold for the town is that's the town cost. Okay, let's just look at look at annual for. Okay, total annual cost. Does that include the that 277 number is the premiums plus the insurance? So that's so that's 24 261 time 12 plus the buyouts. Yeah. Okay. Now, right now I mean 2621* 12 plus the buyout. Sorry. So that that's the actual I just happened to be just before I got this email pulling budget numbers on that same stuff. I came up with 295 budgeted for health insurance and 10,000 for buy comes out to 305 in the budget for where we were looking at all the budgets for that just going through. Y that's across the whole town. Is this our true cost? So we talking about true cost versus budget cost from the invoice. Okay. But yeah, the budget reflects the Yeah. Okay. So how' you come up with 305 and how did you come up with 27? I was looking at the budget amount. He's looking at the actual monthly spend but the budget amount was derived from the actual spend. So department like the PD they asked for additional full-time officer and they partially funded it because we knew we weren't going to hire somebody January 1. Looks like they're not going to get anybody certified anyway. And you hire uncertified. You're talking a year train. Oh, so you had a whole So there was also an insurance line. You don't know if you're going to hire somebody who's single right now. You're not So you were getting numbers from that. Yeah. This is straight budget. His is really I'm not saying that you're wrong. I'm just saying that it's going to be worthy. Okay. A we don't have somebody in that position now. B we don't know who it is. Right. And there's other there's other positions that are right now. So, yeah, you could hire a full-time person today and they could be a family plan and then that will change these numbers. Change your numbers or they could be budgeted for a family plan. I don't remember Dave and I budgeted for something, right? It might be fine on the budget side, but as far as the actual expenditure here, it's going to it's it would change because you're not that's not accounted for. Right. Correct. Right. Okay. So, I've got budgeted 295 for health insurance, 12,3 change for dental, 166,000 for retirement, 97,000 for social security, 620 for life insurance, 6,87 for disability, 10,000 for bio for total employee benefits of 580,000. I mean, social security benefit maybe, but we don't we can't really do anything with social security. That's in retirement. In retirement, that's like the town. Once the town voted to you can some you can police and fire you can't. Other positions you can offer. But that that turns off a lot of people looking for jobs, right? We need just hire people with the 65. Wow. They're not They're not good ditch diggers. I have a question for you, Jeremy. I think I asked this question. Do the employees pay anything? Oh, their insurance like health 15%. Health and dental. Town pays 85. Is this is just health? This isn't dental in here, right? Am I missing? Well, dental Well, no, I'm just saying, but this is just health. Not long. Chances are there's not going to be a lot of money to be saved. Well, right. I'm just saying that's what we're looking at here. Yeah, you can play around with that number. Our buyout is higher than almost anybody. Most towns are like, "What?" Usually, now or something for buyout. No, it's 10. It's 10 for us, but not everywhere else. I'm a single plan and that's 13 grand a year. So even if I didn't take it and we gave you $10,000 check, you still see the school offers me five grand for way higher. But so you have to look at that number. Are other have other towns looked at their health insurance and gone with different plans then that are less expensive? So I went to I don't think we want to be the only town that does that. We do want to get ahead of health trust going belly up. I think a lot I think a lot of towns aren't willing to have their conversation to start with which is a problem. Um, but when I went to the annual meeting last year for health draws, which probably one of the most boring things, I don't know, but the sense that I got from the room was it was a lot of the larger towns that have unions that were speaking they were just saying that um uh like Lebanon and not like cities but larger towns or whatever, but they were saying how because they have to agreements they have, you know, usually you want to take something away, you give something or whatever, but uh they were You could just tell from the way they were talking that they were hurting and feeling it and they were looking at other ways. They needed to look for other ways to Has anyone has anyone done any and has any I know Wilton was with um so it used to be health trust. Yeah. School care and then the third was called interlocal trust. Yeah. The other one's going belly up. He just frantically out of nowhere had to find a new time and I think schoolare took them. But I don't know what their longterm plan is. But most towns didn't even have the dialogue. So nobody wait. So no other town has looked at their health insurance and tried to find a more way. So we'll be kind of like but the idea was to maybe switch over to a plan with a higher deductible but have the town be willing to fund it. So then that way you're actually paying for insurance as they use it, not just cutting a check every month saying you go help us. What is the likelihood of this actually happening? I mean, I think it's pretty high for us. We have to find the right fit, but I think the board's on on board with that for previous experience. I know there's options out there to do it most. So, there's your goal. That's a nice That's a nice goal, right? Like you have it all laid out right there. So, when you're So, I've been talking with insurance agency. insurance. It's different. Insurance information. She's um giving some quote so far meeting with her Thursday to kind of figure out how do we bridge that gap in between? So if we go to a high deductible plan, how do we find in between my card, right? you know, if you totally switch it from no deductible to 5,000 deductible, no helpable, you know, you're taking away a year, right? Well, I think a lot of us too, like who have insurance through different ways, too, like, you know, that's kind of the way of the world right now. Nobody has the gold standard. I'm hopeful there's a way that the town can switch to a higher deductible plan. Find a middle ground to fund it and offset that. I think this is I think you find a higher deductible plan. I never did get this card. Do you want to show us what your insurance is cheap? No, because it's nice. It's changed. I um Yeah, I think you can find the high deductible plan and fund the plan for way less than what we're doing here. And that money rides in those accounts if they don't use it. So, you know, whether it's a health savings account or a reimbursement account. So, all right. So, we'll stay tuned to hear what comes out of that. But Let's be a trend setter on this one. Absolutely. So my my goal of the meeting is to have you know few options. Yeah. Yeah. Because I don't even know right now it's like they don't know. So it's my job to find out. When you when you said selfunded you didn't mean actually pay for claims. You meant pay for the insurance up to the high deductible. I didn't I didn't say so. I mean like um you know switch over a plan where you're actually paying out for for services used on a certain kind of check but but the term self-funded that yeah just they just bring the bills into the town and you pay no third party there's I don't speak insurance but I it does sound that way there's some weird juju magic how they manage because years and years ago I worked for a place we had our dental plan was bring us the bills which drove the doctors crazy. It's I'm like just build a company. They're like what what's your parents? No, build a company. So just just keep in mind when you come back to talk to us about this, we need it from on like the idea of a computer like from like step one. This is what I mean by this language because there's a lot of strange language in the insurance world. I've already learned new new plans and stuff. I mean the the other thing that I've seen done is you give you offer a range of plans and you give them x number of dollars a year you pick what you want that you can use to fund the plans and a lot of companies do that some place some places will pay for your insurance but if you have dependent yeah which I don't not saying you should go that way but you know a lot of people wanted a better plan there were better plans available but you had to pay out of pocket yeah we'll give you 5,000 you $6,000 will be 5,000 and 5,000 will buy this plane. I mean one one of the bargaining chips I've always used that people working in the public sector you know being rich and not make a lot of money but your benefits are pretty good. Yeah, it used to be. But then again, if you're not using it, it's not anymore. You're not using the insurance money, right? Then there's there's two different health type accounts. There's a reimbursement account, which is FSA or HSA or what? FSA and HSA, they're two different things. Yes. Okay. The FSA is a flexible spending account and if you don't use it by the end of the year, they lose it. But there's also a savings. There's an Yeah, there's an HSA where you can save it and it rolls over. There's another one too. Okay. Well, we don't need to Some of them are certain. You can only fund so much. I know. We're not We are not going to solve insurance here. No, I'm just talking about firms. It's confusing. And that's why I'm saying when you come back come back from like how do I turn the computer on point of view with the insurance what do you do right now if somebody's on Medicare you have one retiree that has a separate plan through the town so these These numbers here on the bottom, that's per department. That's currently what we're paying out. Is that different plans? Oh, yeah. That's that's part of the staff. Yeah. Yeah. If they got a single, if you got a staff, if you got three staff in one department and three staff in another department, one of them only has singles and the other one office. You have my single plan and you have Ebie and Sarah who both have the bio. Okay. Sarah really wanted to switch this year and before she got her raise, she's like, I honestly got she probably shouldn't be down here. She's like, I honestly want to switch, but I need the money. I was like, yeah, well, we all need the money. Yeah, but her plan right now with her dad is stay. So, so this is the the monthly premiums are Yeah. single place single two and then a family and a family is three or more. Some people do split. They do dental family and insurance single person. It's a whole thing. All right. All right. Why don't we move on because we're not I was gonna ask one more question. All right. One more question. Steve, if if they have other insurance, will these uh become supplementals if they opt in on them? insurance. I don't think you can do that. I don't think insurance companies will. They Yeah, it'll basically what I can say basically if you have one and your spouse has one, theirs is their primary, yours is your primary and theirs becomes your secondary. So, [Music] not there's some weird laws around that businesses and I'm not I don't I'm not an insurance person. And I just different companies different or even the same company. Yeah. I can get insurance through the school. My husband can be the primary insurance carrier. I can get insurance through the school and use that if his insurance some companies won't do that. Insurance. Well, it's something to learn. There's lose money. Probably not. That might raise the cost. Yeah. So, okay. Well, it might be built in and you might be able to see I thought people wanted to be out by seven. Oh, I didn't know we were under. All right. So, Mr. Obert, are you doing something with pie charts? A yes or no is okay. Not yet. I haven't had I started looking at it. Um I found a way to take the data that comes out of your reports and make a nice clean a nice pretty thing. Nice. All right. So, I've got that's good way to get things in the database and that's what I'm working on right here to get it. So, maybe next time we can throw it up on the screen. So, whatever you have, we can just look at it and see we can all oo and a how beautiful it is. Right. Right. Right now it's not now. It's not beautiful. Okay. All of the line items just stacked sorted by the type. Okay. But it groups I've got all the advertising in one place and all all of that stuff. So that's a start. So in order to um establish whatever cut goal that we're looking at, right? Like because I I I envisioned this as meeting saying we want to do a 10% because they did it right at town meeting. Then we haven't figured out the hard part. Um, so I almost I was thinking we would start with a 10% cut across the board, right? Like like a mock budget of 10%. Do that as soon as possible so that we can start to theorize that amongst ourselves before we we might look at it and go, "Holy crap, there's no way we're doing this." You know, so we might be at 5% or we might be at 2% or might be just let's try to make sure the budget's even going into next year so there's no increase. And that's maybe where we end up. But if we start the 10%, work our way up or work our way down, um we can at least explain at town meeting that we did that went through that exercise. But we've got to start there and we probably have to start there soon because if we do realize that, you know what, I think a 3% cut budget cut is actually realistic. We need to notify department heads about that. We need to talk with the select board about that. Um and it is the operating budget. So the operating budget belongs here. So if we're going to be doing that, we need to be letting people know well in advance before we do it, right? So, so would you would you say the first step in doing this would be to go through and identify the stuff that you can't touch sort of fixed? Yeah, that that's what I would do is I I'd go line by line and look at like is is um yeah, I would look at it line by line and look at the things that are that are fixed costs. Um, one of them might be that if the healthcare thing works out and Jeremy finds that that high deductible plan, I guarantee you that's going to be a a nice chunk. You say once we have a more clear picture on how we should have three to 5% what's it what what's the deductible now the health insurance start none zero it's awesome you know it's so expensive it's like 1950 here in it's time to you know I don't use $13,000 I agree I agree get rid of flint flintstone I know it wouldn't take much to use $13,000 this is what we're talking about like we've got to get with like the current practices. Years ago, I saw proposals of towns going from this to like basically after um the Affordable Care Act came out. We must be the last town in the state. People started figuring out people started figuring out how to work with the affordable care act. I saw proposals for towns where they went from our health trust type plan to total switch to everything's like max deductible for everybody. And then I saw the math where say you had 15 people employees on your plan the whole town and in that one given year every single plan max deductible which we all know would never happen better chance of getting stuck lighting twice or buying the power twice and even with that math the town would still save money covering those deductibles. The bottom line is we're at the health insurance industry mercy in the in the doctors and the hospitals. You know, you get one bill, they bill you this, but if you don't have health insurance, then you get a discounted bill, which is a real bill. Not always. Actually, it's usually the other way around. You know what happens with health insurance company pays this? You know what happens with health every year? We get a letter from them every year saying how much ours is going up. This is this is why it's going up. Oh, that's where Mary was figuring out everybody's amount for that. So that's why I'm saying we're not going to fix it here in Troy, but we don't need to pay for gold standard insurance. That's what we're waiting to find out. Thing that I've seen insurance policies is the difference in the annual cost between several policies that look the same except have different deductible is the amount of the deductible. Yeah. That is the variation for what you're paying for. Yeah. I mean, if if you if you had one plan, it's like, okay, it's $1,500 deductible, let's say, and you wanted one with zero deductible, it cost you another $1,500 a year. So, I'm not sure that paying deductibles would actually save you money based on other Jeremy's going to report back with some fabulous information. Start with stupid so we understand. I didn't I didn't mean to bring health care back up, but I think probably so the way you want to do it, Steve, is is I would do by department, right? What does a 10% cut look by department, right? And then that's going to give us kind of a starting block and and then you can and you start to drill down from there. That would be the first drill down I would do. And that would save you from drilling down right off in the right off the beginning because I think it's going to kind of expose itself as to how far we need to drill down to determine um if this is going to work or not. And we do know healthcare is one of the biggest components. What is that 10% of our overall budget? 7.5. Okay. So 7 and a half% of our budget is that we're obviously not going to be cutting all that. But if Jeremy comes back early enough with some of the um projected numbers, right, because you're going to start talking about these numbers, those plans and and prices are out there. Um maybe we can then start to plug that in and see what that how that affects each of these budgets. Like if we actually end up saving this amount of money on healthcare, then we know that's going to be the biggest chunk. What does that left what does that leave us to have to cut for the rest of that budget? Um that's kind of how I would I would do it. Now, going off the back, do when do I was going to say when would be the next time we meet and do we want to kind of follow how we have it set up? So, we're not going through the entire budget all at once. We break it up into like how we are meeting for like water and library. We the next ones we go through and then we go through like historical chest. So, we kind of break it up by department. So, we're not going through the entire budget all at once. So, I got to thought about that. That's okay. So I I get what you're saying, but I don't think we have enough time for that. So I would say I would say that that we would we wouldn't want to drill down. We wouldn't want to do line by line. That's why I was saying just do by by department budget as a macro number, you know, and then take some of the big key items within that budget to try and see what we can cut with those and then move on, you know, so we can we can get through a whole bunch of the budget in or maybe all of it here for a while. But I would say focus on the bigger budgets. Well, yeah. We don't we probably don't even have to really talk about some of the smaller budgets. You take 10% out of the ZBA budget, it's it's got postage and that's it. Yeah. There isn't really anywhere to save except the bigger bud or the smaller budget. Exactly. I think ZBA is the smallest budget. So, is there a way to like who wants to look at go about doing that. Yeah, that's always how do we break it down? Yeah. Um I I thought Steve was was hungry for this and I would certainly be willing to help with whatever Steve wants me to help with. I can help but my technology expertise is not fabulous. But I would love to learn. Yeah, just plan on the first half an hour just trying to figure out how she gets logged in. Your thought we spent 26 minutes in his microphone. My mic was off the whole time. I'm like I'm like um well I hate to break it to you but that was me. I'm typing too. What the hell are you doing? Which was a relief but anyway. Yeah. No, I would like to learn but yes I'm a little All right. So maybe we can kind of talk okay separately and see how that might work. Okay. Um I'm going to try to figure out who's got the biggest budgets and Okay. Budget cut subcommittee. Steve, Ben, and Jamie. Yeah. Do do you want to, like I said, go through the type of line items that were untouchable. Can we I don't know. I mean, I don't know. I I do better live than the on computer meeting stuff. No matter what I do. Yeah, if we want to get together and meet and kind of look at that how we could do make that happen technology wise and then we can present it at our next meeting here and say this is what we kind of looked at. That makes sense in a large scale like I'd be open to doing that. Oh, okay. Yeah, that would be great. Maybe meet here. If we go to town hall, we can have Jeremy. Well, I'll come here, too. Well, fine. Okay. Whatever. Mileage. I'll come pick you up. So, we'll work that out. All right. We'll work out. Yes. And that way we can have that information. All right. Do we want to talk about impact fees? We don't have the select board here because that they're kind of dragging on, right? What was the discussion about impact fees from us? Impact fees is like when people when a planning board like when a permit's issued for someone building something new, it's like how I know I know what they are, but What was the discussion we had like the idea came up last year like let's sort of a warrant it's not that easy you have to go through the process and it's really a combination between the planning board and select board right so they wanted to have a conversation with Carol and the way her schedule worked she was never going to be able to come to a sequence meeting so that's why we had the joint meeting a couple weeks ago whatever where two of the select were there she couldn't make it but um just had a dialogue Basically, a lot of towns are spending big money to have a consultant go through and make this pretty impact schedule. I don't need to get that done, but basically you have six years to spend the money. So, you could call it you could establish an impact fee tomorrow, but next time you where you know you build a new house and x amount of dollars is charged an impact fee. You have to dictate where it's going to go. Like some towns will do roads. Some towns will do div up or whatever. But so you have to say where it's going, how you're building it. You have to spend it within six years if you're supposed to give it back. And there's two different ways to do it. I don't remember all the details about Do we have enough I was going to say of that to spend money on a fancy consultant and all the energy that's going to take to put into it to have that kind of like the dialogue with the master plan, right? Southwestern Community Services region planning. So they're gonna come back with a quote for how much it's going to be to work at our master plan. We're just waiting for how big that's going to be. So yeah, the question of what it's going to look like and what you're going to charge, how much you're going to charge and where it's going to go. They just had their preliminary first discussion with Carol board. Yeah. Somebody's going to have to down and figure out how much it's going to have to go on next year's ballot. All right. I mean, they're pretty they're pretty common, but there's a less strict way of doing it and some towns have opted into that way and apparently they're not actually following through with it. So, it's kind of like a waste of effort. We don't need to burn money, right? We don't need to put effort into something. Yeah. So little update on that is that at this point in time we are looking at working just with Carol and that'll just be a little bit in addition to our consulting budget impact fees or for master plan that one of the Did you guys get a quote yet or no? They did not get us a quote yet, but we did um look for instead of the quote for them doing more just for um looking at the land use change since our last master plan update. Um and that was going to be about $700. Um that would be Carol that would that'd be through Southwestern. Um actually I think that Henry is that's one of his department. Um so we are working on just basically doing an update to the vision and the land use um section. Those are the two required sections. The rest of it is optional. And I mean a couple weeks ago, I don't think it was at the line where came in, but in our discussions about the master plan update, it became apparent, at least to me, that um the planning board did not really have any desire for change or anything. It's updating for the sake of updating. So, we believe that we can do this somewhat affordably. Again, that $700 number that we heard last time. And I think they're going to be cut down the line. Yeah. Do they talk about impact fees again or um that we're not going to really be touching that until we have the master plan update rolling. So, I mean, I'm sure that we will bring it up, but it's just it won't go anywhere. It sounds like a next year project, next year or end of the year or something that we don't really have anywhere to go with it at this point in time. Potential additional revenue. Well, I like I like the approach on the on the master plan update because frankly, it's just put on the shelf and collected dust since 2007. So, yeah, most people agree that it's pretty good. Yeah. No, we got a great I think we spent all kinds of money on it the first time around and we've got a great master plan. Hopefully, a lot of it still, you know, we're just anticipating the quote to be I mean, they didn't budget anything for it to begin with. Exactly. And that again we're looking at it and like our survey from last year basically people still felt the same way that we were seeing no major changes. We're not and again looking from the board's perspect listening to the discussion at the board that's like we're not wanting to make a major change for something updating for the sake of updating. So hopefully okay all right yeah updated master plan makes the cip legitimate makes the impact fees legitimate so that's also that how often you supposed to update it But if nothing has changed, then that's kind of silly to invest tons of money. Exactly. Right. There was the survey that came out of town folks are not thinking we need to do anything crazy. Why are we Exactly. One of our meetings there that a member even said, "Well, how about we just eat it into AI?" So that at that point in time it becomes apparent that okay we're not trying to change something because something's changing the town right that we're updating when Ronda was going after we had update our emergency management plan right you know what those plans we do that was good though they did get updated now they're we don't want but you're actually legally required to update There we go. Um I I don't anyone have anything in particular about the bud the year-to- date budgets that they want to point out? Um I looked at I went right down through and um I thought everything was looking pretty good. You know, just Yeah, the end numbers. Yeah, the end numbers were looking good. Um yeah, we're 41 this as of this date. We're 41% of the way through the year. And um we have in most departments we have more way more than 41% left. I mean 60 60% of the budget left. So it was good. I went just just juggling through there's there's stuff that's in probably posted the wrong place because there is zero zero dollar item lines with money against them and no. Yeah. So that's a good point though, Steve, but on our goals list, and it's not necessarily our goal, but it would be nice not to have to because what the budget committee does on a regular basis is we are the audit firm for the transaction entries, which we really should not that should absolutely not be that that way. It should be some sort of dual control going on in your office, Jeremy, where where on a month- over-month basis, somebody goes back through and just looks through all the transactions and looks for, you know, red flags like that and says, "Okay, this can't be right because we've over spent that budget line by 200% or something." Zero, you can't charge anything. Zero, you can't put anything in there. So, you know, just little things like that. It would be nice to adopt a process within the selection's office to catch that so that when we're going into the budget season, we're not doing this what Steve was doing. Basically looking at him going, "What's going on here?" I wasn't looking for that. I was just looking at something. Yeah, we like Steve's free labor. Well, no, but then it's that throws things off. I mean, if things aren't going into the right account and you know, we haven't appropriated any funds. If there's a zero, that should be like a a signal that some we're putting something here that shouldn't be going here. What would be nice is if we could put this kind of thing into a requirements document and then feed them to me and I'll see if there's something I can do with the database. Okay. I'm I'm trying to design the database here looking at stuff and it helps to know what you want to do. How are you how are you building the database? Are you getting it from this report? Are you able to transfer that in? Yep. No Good. Good for you. That's that's good because it is hard cutting back shifting his priorities. It's it's hard to do the delimination on on this report because then it and it comes out it's it's if you get it exported in Excel, it's just it doesn't come out right. Well, the trick is to to take the PDF and do one online PDF to spreadsheet things and then it it comes out as it comes out. Okay. All right. I hope you guys are ready for to give me the weekend for this technology. Too. All right. Okay. But the the question comes in is if you want to actually look at actuals, they need to be done on a reg on a regular basis. So you can do percentage, you know, what happened in Janu, we need like a report at the end of January, February, that kind of thing. So can we add that to the list of reports that Sarah puts out? So the budget committee gets a the full budget once a month. You know, the departments get a budget a consistent day like the first day of the month or Right. Right. Right. As of as Yep. As of as of the last day of the month, I would that's how I would do it. And I um because because the departments get them on a monthly basis or I don't know how regularly they're getting them, but that's what they're supposed to. And if the budget committee just got a full budget on a on a monthly basis, that'd be slick. That would serve your purpose, right, Steve? Yeah. I mean, this this report has a period, expendables, and a current year. Yes. And basically, they're the same all the time because the period is set to the full year. Yep. So, just changing that would probably help. Boy, we are nerds. Well, you need to go back and month by month now or is it too late to not worry about It's not that hard. Not important right now. I'm I'm working on design stuff here. Let me do let me know and one of these days I'm going to have some time. I'm going to come and sit with you. I'm going to look and see what I already warned Sarah so she knows it's coming. Oh, you're no fun. So that the end of our budget questions for the moment. So now next meeting you want year to date once a month on the same same day. Yeah, we want revenue. Yeah, revenue. Yeah. Yeah. I think what Steve was saying there is in that year to date report, you would you would set the parameters for the period expend the expenditures for only that month. Is that right, Steve? So, you'd still have a year date number on there, but you would have just these. Oh, yeah. Yeah, that sounds that's pretty awesome. Because you want to be able Yeah. build it up over, you know, pull that column, dump it in the database. Now you can look at at how where it went wrong. got a June 1st date instead of May for the month of May we get your your year to date as of date would be May 31st and your period um parameters would be May 1st through May through the 31st that's how you would set it and the good news is that you you can go back and do this you know it's not like well we missed the date I would be flipping through a paper a pencil and paper book doing that All right. Well, I'm trying. Oh my god. That's what I grew up with. I didn't work. I remember that. Yes. I see the cash dispersement sheets. I know. Way out there. All right. Any old business? Everybody look away. Any public comment? No. No public presence. All right. Next meeting. Oh, schedule the next meeting. Okay. Um, should we get one a month? So, after July 7th, I'm not I'm not available. What are we going to do? Committee then? Yeah. Like starting July 7th, I'm I'm never available again. Sounds like a plan. Not available for I'm going to need more than a month. It's pumpkin season, isn't it? No, not yet. That that plays a role, too. All right. So, after July 7. Oh, well, the week we're not But before that would be better. The fourth. No, we're not doing the fourth. Um, oh, good lord. Do we want to meet on the 30th? I mean, do we think we can figure out the 10%. I think so. Absolutely. And that because we really have to because we otherwise we're not just not going to get has no time to get it done. All right. So, June 30th, I think that's 6 o' I might be then. That's the first day of summer camp. You can come with coffee. Have coffee. I want to have him. Tristan can come and ride. I'm tired. table. It's a Monday. It's a Monday. This room is pretty safe on Monday. Oh, right. That's right. Can we have this room on Monday? I didn't see any bookings for Monday's period. So, all right. Cuz the library is closed. Okay. Are you going to add us to the calendar? I will. All right. Thank you. All right. So, what do I say? Are we Oh, I'll I'll take a motion to adjourn. Is that I'll I'll move that we adjourn this meeting at 7:28 p.m. Yeah. too. That's Al's version of the second. All in favor? I That was a unique second. I liked that. All right. Good night. Good day. All right. So,