MVRSD School Board Meeting 6-9-2026
The Board approved minutes from May 26 and subsequently addressed student concerns regarding course cuts under the 10-student policy. During public comment, students from Canaan and Enfield argued for the retention of advanced classes like Honors Physics to ensure academic rigor and eligibility for sports and college. Several speakers emphasized the need for better student representation. Financially, the district faces a projected 20% health insurance increase ($1.2 million) and has a Fresh Picks lunch balance deficit of $14,063.36. The Business Administrator reported pending legislation (HB 1610) that could eliminate the ability to retain $650,000 in unassigned fund balance for emergencies. The Board approved encumbrances totaling $259,286, including a mixed-use school bus van, phonics materials due to a new state mandate, and auditorium lighting. A three-year plowing and mowing bid for $268,968 was awarded to MTD Property Management. The Board granted the superintendent authority to hire and accept resignations through the summer months. Staff nominations and resignations were accepted. The next meeting is a retreat scheduled for June 24. Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=faSAvEhte3c
Please rise and join me for the Pledge of Allegiance. >> I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. >> All right, first thing we have on our agenda is approval of minutes, public and non-public from May 26th. I'll entertain a motion on that. >> I'll make a motion to accept the minutes, public and non-public. >> You don't have to hold it. You can just tap it and it'll But now I think you turned it off. There, now you're on. All right, do we have a second? >> I'll second. >> All right, cool. Um all right, any comments, questions, concerns, changes, anything on the minutes? I didn't see anything. It looked great. All right. Seeing no comments, all those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? Any abstentions? All right. First thing we're going to do is we're going to stick to our agenda as we have written because the other continuing business stuff is pretty quick, but this is public comment, so if you have any public comment at this time, just state your name, what town you're from for the for the minutes, and yeah. >> Are there any student speakers at this time? >> Yeah, if you have student speakers who would like to speak to this, I mean this would be a fine this would be a good time to do it. >> Okay, so you just have to walk up, state your name, your purpose, and share. You have 5 minutes. >> Uh my name is >> Hey, that one has them too. All right. >> My name is John >> All right, yes. >> My name is Jordan Button. I'm [clears throat] from Canaan, and I'm talking about the class theme cut. Uh ever since I moved here in 6th grade, I've been a advanced uh in advanced classes ever since 7th, which was the earliest they were allowed. Uh I played sports and sports. And uh my main problem is the cutting of honors physics. It's the only high level science class that will be offered next year and the only class that would reasonably fit my credit requirements to graduate. Our school displays the phrase that Masco will inspire you to build the path you want to take every day both on the board to pass her by and on the website for anybody who visits it. I don't understand how you can be cutting a class with six or eight people even five in some cases when that is our entire school's identity. I understand that some of the very small classes somewhere from like the two to four range that's not enough kids to run a class and that makes sense. That's too too small of a group. But when you have a reasonably sized group of high level students they don't deserve to not have that class based solely on the numbers. My own cousin she was a 2017 graduate from Masco. She is a PhD student at UMass Med Chem. She wrote a letter addressing the cutting of high level science classes. If I be allowed to pass it on. >> Yeah, just go ahead and pass it on. Yeah. Thank you. >> And then you >> You just turn off the video. There you go. Now you're good. >> And then if anybody else would like one, uh they're available. Okay. Uh obviously the main highlight of her uh letter is the high level science classes. Actually it does study science, but it's very applicable to the other ranges of classes because a lot of classes being cut are high level classes. Many of them require pre-req- prerequisites, and many have built a schedule around this class. And that's specifically even me. I was a freshman year going into honors biology that my path could either be chemistry this year and then physics next year, or physics and last year, and then chemistry this year. But so I built my schedule around that, and now I won't have a high level science next year. When I want to go to third and then senior year for observational astrophysics. And obviously I'm talking from a very small point of view from just a few students, but even that small body has had over half of their schedule in the discussion of being cut. And just imagine the impact on a student body as a whole. With the requirement of five classes for to play sports, to be in student council, to be in any clubs, that is a high concern for many people. That's all I have. >> Thank you so much. >> Yeah, thank you. >> All right, who would like to go next? All right, just name and town. >> Hello, my name is August Abbott. I'm from Cannon. I'm mostly following up on what Storm said. He said that um both we can our point of view is only from a small group of people, and that's not because a small percentage of our grade feels this way. This is because our grade itself is very small. And we have between 50 and 60 people, which means that this 10th grade um student body is only 20% of our entire grade. And when you're thinking about this in terms of how small our grade is, and really how small our school is, you start to think about the issue of homogenization of these classes. If we're only allowing classes that the most people are taking, that is going to be the lower level classes. And if we're cutting the higher level classes, so then there won't be any higher level classes left, and there will only be the lower level classes. And so, there won't be any opportunities for anyone to go farther beyond what's expected. That's all. >> Cool. Thank you so much. >> I have a question. >> All right, good. >> Hello, I'm Carl Russell. I'm from Enfield, and I'll be a senior here next year. Um Most importantly for me in this matter of the 10-person policy is that I signed up for six classes to take next year, six credits worth of classes. And the NHIAA requires five uh for a student to be eligible to do sports. Now, Spanish four is a credit. French one is a credit. Ancient World History is half a credit, and Intro to Philosophy is half a credit. That makes three. If those don't run, I'm not for three credits, and I'm not eligible to be an athlete next year for my senior year. I've been running since fourth grade. I've been competing for the district in cross country and track and field since fifth grade. I was 10 then. I'm 17 now. And I've been on teams, and I've helped teams compete for and win championships in cross country and track and field throughout middle school and high school. I finished seventh at the state championship for cross country last year. I'm the fourth place returner. I have very high hopes for this season. And more importantly than my my position, there's a very good-looking team around me next year, both on the girls' side and the guys' side. And I will be a returning captain for that team. And I would be sorely disappointed to miss out on my senior season and to miss out on the chance to work with that group of athletes in cross country and indoor track and in outdoor track if these classes don't get exceptions. Thank you. >> All right. Thank you. All right. >> Uh hello. I am Tristan Clark. I am from Canaan. I [clears throat] will be a senior next year at Mascoma High School. Uh my main point for my addressing the school board tonight was not so much specific classes or personal issues as much as it was the future of students in Mascoma. I feel as though well, I personally was not aware that this meeting was even happening until a couple days ago. And I felt like I would this is a very important meeting, so I should probably be involved in a meeting based around decisions that affect me. Cuz the point of a democracy is you know, give all people a voice. So, uh tonight I came here with a lot of research done on as much as I could get in a few days time on how much we give our students a voice in Mascoma. And uh I've learned that as far as I have been able to find, the New Hampshire state law just requires the school board to have student rep, which we do. Uh I'm going to lock it. But um from what I've learned is that the school board has not exactly been able to ensure that any student rep, even previous student reps, have been able to completely fulfill the duties of their job. Not educated fully in what their job is required or how to complete their job, and I feel that results in a lack of communication with students. And my main issue with that is that in the future and even in the present, students do not have a voice in decisions made regarding them because of this issue. So, I'm not here as much to discuss classes, like I said previously, as much as I am to ask that the school board establish or enforce any previous president that states that they need to ensure students have a full voice. If it were a poll on future decisions or just an email in general to students, because I have a list here of 37 uh students who I got to sign this, and I would think 32 of them had no idea this meeting was even happening. And I have seven freshmen, 10 sophomores, 19 juniors, and one senior, all of which uh agreed that the school board does not give students enough representation in decisions regarding students' future. So, I would just very much like to ensure that the school board is aware that the students feel as though they do not have enough representation and would pursue making sure students feel that they have enough representation. Thank you. >> Uh thank you. >> Yeah, thank you. >> All right. Anybody else? >> Greg Russell Enfield. Uh I guess I'm up here as a very proud parent really really happy to see all these students are going with my son who's speaking to you tonight, and I'm still a faculty. Appreciate you guys taking the time. Um So, my comments are probably a little broader than what your agenda is for this but um I I I'd encourage you to just do away with the 10 students per class policy. Refocus, reprioritize on a full spectrum of classes for all of our students. Um education, of course, is is for every student, including those who are prepared for college. And as we are starting the college application process, they're they're requiring rigorous schedules, you know, 4 years of languages, the same language, 4 years of math, 4 years of sciences, and they're expecting them to take those classes during their senior year. Um if we're if we're not offering a full range of classes, then we stop being a complete high school. And and that's really important. And I'll just let you know, education's worth paying for. This high school, this whole district is worth paying for. Please please consider allowing these small classes to run. Thank you. >> Thank you. All right, anybody else like to speak? Yeah? But I I am impressed with the amount of student engagement at this meeting. So, I'm really happy to see this many students out. This is exactly what we hoped to have. In many meetings, there is nobody here, so All right, go ahead. Just state your name and town as well for the record. >> Uh I'm Cole Grolady. I'm from Orange. I was in the Great Swamp, but um I have seen the list of classes that are either that are up to be canceled. Um many of which are classes that I'm either currently in or have taken. All of those classes are ones that I've considered to be the most influential in my classes in my school career. And I think focusing on the number of kids in a class that are interested in a class opposed to what those students that want to take it will get out of the class is not the right agenda for a high school in general, cuz we should be more focused on having a on pushing students to do their best, even if that means they aren't taking the easiest classes that they think they'll do the best in, but having the option for students to push themselves. Because in many of those classes I've taken, such as AP European History and other language classes, they show so much more about how if you just take the easy way, you will not learn nearly as much as if you struggle than if you struggle through a class to get to a point that you're happy with yourself. >> Thank you. >> All right, thank you. All right, anybody else? Okay, so now for real, this is this is a lot of student engagement, so we really like to see this. Um, we're just going to get through the rest of the continuing business real quick, and then we'll take a blast off projections uh just down there. So then we'll talk about it and have a nice robust discussion. All right, coming up next and because I did that because Abby did say that she had something to say about this in her report, so Abby, >> I just have a small thing. It's more of a summary if anything about how the student body has voiced their concern about classes being cut and reworked and combined with other classes. And that many students feel that it's unfair because it limits their academic growth, and some students have even voiced to me that they feel that the school is prioritizing the metrics of classes over all over their students' educational experience. That's really all I have in my report. >> Okay. >> For everything else, baseball and softball have finished up. They fought baseball on a solid final week, and softball is just continuing working on improvement. Track and field had an amazing season. They had their college signing night on the 5th, and they had a couple awards, and it was just overall a great season. For the arts, music, they we performed at the Canaan Memorial Day parade and marched in Enfield and it was pretty amazing. Right now we're preparing for playing for graduation. For the art department, there's a lot in the packet. I'll just go over a little bit. Just It was overall exceptional. Many students had many amazing achievements, the community engagement, and great artistic opportunities. There's many field trips, the art foundation, hot glass blowing, Stephen Proctor for these huge pots, and then a couple of raccoon things at Colby-Sawyer. It was just overall one of the best years for art possible. For clubs, student council, the spring fling went well and we're holding elections on the 10th of this year. Um NHS, we've elected our officers and the faculty breakfast went amazing. Um Not much more. DI, we all know what they did with the donation. They played 17 to the whole world at Global Fest, which is very amazing. Other school news, just IRS, we'll have step up day on Friday morning, and see EBS, they've begun their field trip schedule and fourth graders are heading to the NH State House. Kearsarge fourth grade and EBS are going to meet up for some fourth graders at IRS. On June 4th at IRS for field day activity. And a couple of students and first graders went to Belly Swirl, and kindergarten and third graders went to Squam Lake. And coming up each fourth grade class will go to Shaker Museum. >> Cool. All right, thanks Abby. Any questions for Abby from the board? All right. Uh next we have finance facilities. You can see the minutes in your packet there. Uh we met last week. Uh we will get to the low no salt zone requests on Canaan Street, so we'll talk more about that later in the agenda. Um but that seemed pretty good and Butler's bus gave that their blessing. They said it should be totally fine and not affect their routes, so that was good. Matt and Matt and Dan gave their report getting ready for graduation, getting ready for summer work. All the summer hire help has been hired and all that. Um talked about some finance stuff, CAP and audit. There's nothing much there. Talking a little bit about the budgets. Um health insurance is major increase where budget and we're budgeting a 20%. Is that correct, Michelle? We're going to Okay, so we're going to go in assuming it's going to rise by 20%, so that would be $1.2 million, so that's really fun. So we talked a little bit about that and supply costs. Um graduation costs going up as well. Uh contracted services, talked about fresh picks negative lunch balance. This was as of last week was negative $14,063.36. Uh of that 80 about 8,300 is at the high school, 4,800 at IRS, and then the other two schools are fairly small. Um they're talking trying to figure out how to do this, but that's about what we're going to have to look at for the end of the year to take from unencumbered fund balance, so Um that's transportation. We did talk about the credits of bus routes that were missed from December through April, so we have a credit going there. Um talked about recruitment for drivers. They're already short three drivers and what our contingency plans are. Um also talked about starting the year with the longer routes and splitting if we need to instead of what we did last year where we thought we had enough drivers and did not, so. Um also talked about, you know, bus vans instead and what that sort of thing. Mixing buses and going back to mixing buses on some of them and what that would look like, so. Um there is going to be Um we're going to use our first meeting in August to to talk about the bus routes, so we will have that. Um and then yeah, that's that's pretty much it as far as my responsibilities. Any questions on any of that stuff? All right, I know it's really All right, up next is Superintendent's Report, Amanda. >> So, you have my written report in your packet. Uh congratulations to Zachary County and Jade Montebianchi for their excellent presentations as seniors at the Hartford CTC program. Um it's always a great spring meeting when I get to go and see our kids present. I believe we had five presentations and two of those were Masuk alumni. >> That's right. >> Uh very very nice representation, very nice showing. Um very proud of those two guys. Um you can see there are two retirement celebrations coming if anyone from the board would like to attend. See yes on June 17th at 1:30. Uh the high school's here at June 17th at 1:00. It's a tight turnaround. Once again, the last day for students will be June 17th and as is tradition, it will be an early dismissal day. Um Can I want to jump right in and just talk to the students a little and say good job, guys. >> Yeah. >> Well done. Um I especially appreciate the fact that some of you came in and said, "Here are the classes that are important to us." I think that was well done. Um and not accusing the board of cutting anything. No, nothing's been cut. Nothing's been cut, right? We've had discussions on this. The school board does need to approve any classes that are 10 or fewer and you guys coming here and advocating for why these classes are important, well done. Well done. That's appropriate use of student voice and I much appreciate that. Um as for school board um student member training, we sent someone out for training. Um so, those things can be questions. Um I'm happy to answer those at any time. So, there is a summer session of training. Did Do Abby? Not yet? No. So, we do offer it um and we do pay for it for them to go offsite and meet with all student members from all the other schools and districts in the state. So we do provide some training for that. >> to point out that we just started doing that in the last two years. So we are we are trying to do >> It's fully staffed Yeah, so absolutely. So at this point I think that's all I have. I think we've done pretty good job of speaking to the things that are important to our students here. So thank you. >> Thank you. All right, any questions for Amanda? Anything out of the ordinary? Yeah, pop quiz anything out of the ordinary. I know you can do it for me. All right, business administrator's report financials we have financials in our packet and Michelle's report here as well. She's not ready you're not ready to give us a final amount because we're still working through the books. >> I'm not ready. >> That's fine. >> I'm ready to work on the income versus though you're going through it with EP payroll it's going to be easier if I can wait for the last payroll to run. Last payroll of the year is June 18th. I think it's a holiday. Um I'm just going to have one here. I also yeah so the the bill house bill 1610 is also an important um legislative act that I need to wait for to see if um I guess signed in cuz that will dramatically >> Yeah. >> change if we retain >> That would dramatically change it. Yes. >> You want to explain that to the board ahead of time? >> Yeah. Yeah, if you can explain to some other board members >> I tried cuz I put a little a little note in there. So it it's going to reduce so right now we retain 5% up to 5% >> Of the total budget, right? >> Of the um of the other side >> Of the other side fund balance. >> So it's >> No, the total budget. >> The total budget. >> Yeah yeah yeah, I'm sorry I'm sorry I confused my numbers. >> Yeah, 5% of the total budget. Um which is for us like 1.3 million but we retain about 650 usually every year. Um the bill would reduce that would would eliminate it for this year. It would go down to to nothing and then you could vote to retain three up to 3% by voters. >> But the voters would have to approve that every year that we would be able to retain up to 3% if that was left over. >> Right. >> Okay. >> Yeah, there's some fair significance with this bill and it looks like it is going to be signed by the governor. So essentially it is preventing us immediately this year from retaining that $650,000 that we use for in case of emergencies. >> Mhm. >> In and in last year's case we used it to pay for the health insurance shortage. So without that money there would have I I don't know what we would have done to find $650,000 in the budget in December. So there is some significant issue with the signature of that. So if anyone wants to advocate that the bill thanks Ron for state level, there you go. >> Yeah, and then this is not and get into the one about um budget caps being voted on statewide. >> No, that's HB 1300. >> one. >> Statewide budget cap voted on in 2026 and again in 2028, which would make it so that our budget could only be if we had a state tax or if we have a tax cap that would mean that the budget could not exceed the previous year's operating budget except for adjust for the cost of living. So that's a pretty significant issue. I don't know what that means on a default budget. So say our budget didn't pass. And you know, it has been very important to me to provide for our students and to make sure that the budget increases acceptable. You know, we've worked really hard to do that. We've got the declining enrollment that we have been able to cut funds through attrition as teachers retire, which is didn't need to fill those at the elementary schools. So, you know, it's this tax cap state wide could have a significant detrimental effect on public education. >> Yeah, and that would be voted on in in November and not March during town meeting. So, their thought is that there's higher voter turnout in November and so therefore they feel like it would be Yeah, I think they feel like it would be more of an inclined to pass a tax cap. >> That's good. >> gamble, I think. Yes, Laura. >> Um so, the state New Hampshire doesn't want to fund public schools. We're like the worst in the whole country, right? And now we're not letting districts >> Mhm. >> raise money for emergency funds? >> That's correct. >> that we'll definitely have to do some advocating and to sort of reach out to the voters for that. Not for this year, it sounds like, but for the next year's 3% and I I mean it would have been in so much trouble if we hadn't had that money for the insurance increase this past year. >> Yeah, exactly. >> Yeah, exactly. We'll see what happens with districts like in in in that are in more dire financial straits that have to lay off staff. We saw Fairpoint last year and Newport and stuff like that. >> Franklin. >> Franklin, that's right. >> New found. >> New found. I was going to say I wasn't going to keep naming schools, but we might get It is bad. >> It's sad for public education. >> It is very unfortunate. There are a lot of schools >> with million dollar deficits. >> Yeah, Franklin has a tax cap right now and they did not override it, I think, recently. >> That's unfortunate. >> Yeah, it is. So, it's really hurting districts. So, we really are hopeful that maybe it doesn't pass, but I'm glad that we have school people in our office to >> paying attention. >> Cuz I know you guys are paying attention cuz not every Not every district is paying attention, so. All right. Any other questions for Michelle? I know it's great stuff. All right. Do we have any updates on bus routes at this time? >> I do not. We gave all the happy news about being down three drivers to start the year. >> Down three drivers. So, if anyone knows someone with a CDL with passenger licensure, let us know. All right, here we go. Class size projections. So, let's just get into this. All right, hello Tina. Hello Ms. Fleming, how are you? >> I am very good. >> Wonderful. Thank you for encouraging the students to come out tonight. >> So, I'm going to share a story about that. So, you know, I watched the other here at the school board meetings. I'm watching them at home and you can just imagine how well I slept the last meeting. Anyway, at 9:00 in the morning, on Wednesday morning, I had two students in my office saying, "What is going on?" And they had real questions and I had no answers. I had already rallied with our school counselors at 7:30 in the morning and was prepping to meet with our curriculum coordinators as soon as I could. So, I would say a storm in August. Um, it seems that they've been the spokesman of the group and sharing information as we as they met with me, they met with me probably nearly every other day since the last school board meeting. So, I'm super proud. One of the things that we've really focused on is student voice. All of our assemblies are run by students and again, we're seeing that here. Student They ran the assembly today. But again, I'm really proud of you guys for coming out, standing up, getting the facts first, which I totally appreciate and respect, and then really bringing your voice to this because it does matter. And I think I was surprised with all the students here. So, I'm really, really proud of them. Um, at the last school board meeting, the Masconomet Regional High School school counselors met to review curriculum and review curriculum coordinators met to brainstorm ways to address the low class size class size numbers concerns that you had. The curriculum coordinators deciding on it was great. We had a great meeting. They brainstormed looking at ways of recruitment, looking at justifications which you have, and even suggesting uh consideration of a 7-period day. The staff has rallied to do this work, and students are speaking up, as you can see. Tonight, I give you some ways the class size numbers can be addressed, and provide you with justifications from the curriculum department curriculum coordinators. This is not a guidance issue. This is a math problem at Valley Regional High School, and the staff and students are united in our approach to support the learning and academic growth of students, as well as working within the policy. We respect that. You have two things. You have the justification pages for the low class size numbers mentioned in the meeting. You also have the work that has been done thus far to figure this out. Um so, at the top of the page, um I will give you an opportunity if you have any questions for me um as you review. Um I believe that the student voice is important. I respect the choices related to classes less than four. Um I do think that we have to recognize that the teacher is not teaching, they're covering a study hall. Is that really the best use of our teachers? Um we want student engagement with the policy going down to just three required classes in the building. We're We need to keep students in the building, and if they're choosing classes, we should keep them. Um one of the considerations we looked at with 7-period models again, and and that's not really the point of this, but really keeping kids engaged in our building and in our school. And if we can't offer these things, then we're not keeping our kids in the building and giving them the education that they're really demanding. These are student requests. These are not assigned. Outside of the freshman classes who are assigned, these are for who chose these classes. So, um I totally respect, you know, some of the decisions, but as far as the students, like our staff, they want to teach. They don't want to be in study hall. They want to teach our kids. So, I'll give you a few moments to look that over. If you have any questions, um please let me know. >> Okay. All right. So, thank you for this data. So, this one packet is from faculty and staff. >> Those are the curriculum coordinators. >> Curriculum coordinators, thank you. Just so that is statements from curriculum coordinators. And then this chart here, I do appreciate this, um where you took the school board comment, the adjustment, and the result. Um so that that is helpful. Um so, I I mean, I see some solutions came about, like you came up with some that I think were fixed, right? If I'm reading this correctly. >> So, So, let me look at this. So, pipe on, I respect that. Um percussion, Mr. Griffin, he can work within that. He also suggested we can maybe lose some students from band into that curriculum coordinator. Honors physics, so the student voice related to honors physics, I think it's been heard. Um I hope you understand that. Um when we look at ancient world history, um you know, same thing. Mr. Sweeten has a great justification in there and can't move it because in some of these classes, we lose students if we combine them. We don't want to lose students and I respect that some of these classes are low, but when we lose students, then what are we doing? Like kids won't learn. Um and that happens in the case of history and film, intro to philosophy. Um so, if you do that, then we lose students. Four students get dropped, combining we lose two um for intro to philosophy. >> So, the result is that students that have been like, "All right, well, I'm not going to do this." They've already decided that they're not going to do those classes, or is that would that be the result of me >> the eight-period schedule does not allow the student to move into that class because of their other schedule classes. >> I got it. So so like for example, social studies history and film it says, you know, we could combine it into one class. But then it says can't combine but we'll drop four students and then the result would be four students dropped. So those students haven't already dropped it. They're in limbo right now. I just want to make sure nobody's already like thrown in the towel and >> Students don't actually know their schedule right now. So we actually did a survey um to we gave teachers the opportunity to recruit. In that, they didn't The students don't know nor do the teachers really know at this point who's in the classes because it's like this big maze, honestly, when I look at it and somehow Mr. Ramage and Ms. Vivian just can read this class input. They don't The students don't know so they Some of the students re-signed up for the same class that they were actually involved in. And I'm just happy they're advocating multiple times over. So um that is what happens. So like no, the students do not know. They can't drop anything. They chose these classes so we got to keep that in mind. >> Okay. All right, any questions from the board? All right, Joe, go ahead. >> Um the last time that we talked at this, there was um I heard somewhere in the neighborhood of like 99% of class classes that kids chose were kept. Is that right? >> Yes, so I heard your comment and thank you very much cuz I do work really hard and I think that's the advantage like that was amazing, right? Um I think we want that, right? We want to achieve that and I know it's a high achievement. Um in other models we keep running models just to be clear about this to see what we can do. Um but then we always reduce it and it's hard It'll be hard for me to look at a student be like, "Sorry, like we can't get you in." Um and that's my job. Um and we can do that and I'll do that if that's what I have to do. But that is exactly like combining we'll lose kids. So that our model percentage number goes down because now we've lost a couple kids out of different classes. So it it was it was high which was really when they looked at it in school counselors did, they were like really impressed with how high it was. >> Okay. >> Yeah, I have a few things to say. I'm super passionate about this. So, I really agree with what you guys said. I think that from a college standpoint, it's really important to have like vigorous options that are challenging. And then I think that if we talk to recruiters from like colleges around from like community colleges, state colleges, Ivy League colleges, they would all tell you the same thing that they want to see students taking these classes. I also think from a teacher's perspective, of course we would want them to be teaching things that make inspire them and they're passionate about rather than having them run study halls. If we already have the teachers, why would we not utilize them fully. I think that that makes everybody kind of happier. And I think that, you know, from strictly from an academic standpoint for the students, like I totally agree and I'm super excited to see you guys all show up tonight because we should have tons of options for learning in the school. That's how we're going to keep it strong. So. >> All right. >> Alice. >> Scott and then Damon. Damon. Okay, go ahead. Go ahead, Scott and then >> Sorry. >> Sorry, it was Scott first and then Damon. >> Hi. First of all, thank you for coming. I think it's really important that you have a voice and I want to remind you that we meet every second and fourth Tuesday of the month. So, you're welcome to bring your voice to our meeting anytime. We appreciate it. We're all parents here. Three of us have had students who have gone through the high school who have taken upper level AP honors classes and they have served our children well and we want to see that they serve you well as also. My question is to you And we will hear it. I heard there's only two kids in a class or I heard there's only five kids in the class from the public. And what do we say to them? How do we convince them? How can you convince them? What can you do to convince the public? Because quite frankly, you know, I'm sure your parents have told you as well, their taxes are pretty high. Property taxes and a lot of times people blame the school and it is not all the school. I will tell you that right from the beginning. But that's who they come back and blame. They blame the school. So how do we convince people? How do we get you guys out there talking to people and saying, "Hey, you know, Nashoba is a great school. We we want to have the opportunities that people in the past have had. You know, think about it. You know, I think it's great. I think you should get the classes you want. My son was a science major in college, so he did those physics and chemistries and so forth. Um and you need those. I support that. Help us figure out how to convince others when it comes time to have them after us. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. >> All right. Thank you, Diane. Scott, go ahead. >> All right. Just uh First of all, I want to thank you all for coming out. You make a very compelling case. And I was already I mean, first the whole board I think was looking for ways to make things work to start with. I don't I anyone sitting here that isn't in favor of offering every course that we've been offering to give you all the opportunities that will help you move it forward. So, we're we're in your court. We already were. And this makes it even easier to be in your court. You The fact that you're here and representing the student body so well is in and of itself part of the compelling case that you make. So, mainly I just want to thank you for coming out. Um I personally am in support of doing whatever we can to make this happen. Diane's point is true. We have to be able to justify it. But, I think there's lots of ways to justify it or at least make the attempt. At the end of the day, we can't guarantee what is going to be approved by voters for budget at the end of the year. We unfortunately do have to take that into consideration, but I want you to know that the At least personally for sure, and I think in general as a board, you do have our support. So, thank you for coming out tonight. >> Thank you, Joe. >> And uh um Again, I'm echoing the board when it comes to the support that you guys have shown in this. Um the one piece here that I think is of note, I'm I'm a teacher myself. I've been in education for 20 years. Um the thing that I go back to also is an equity issue when it comes to teachers in the sense that if you see a uh as a as a co-worker having a class of 20 every five to six periods you know, having 80 kids that you have to grade, and then you have classes that are running at five, seven, and eight. That is a uh that is a struggle for some educators. Um so, because you're busting your hump to do all of this for certain for for some lower level classes that are required and then you have AP classes. Not saying that the workload isn't heavy, but it is something to keep in mind here when we talk about this. Yeah. >> So one of the things we have great curriculum coordinators and they work within their departments to make the class size make the classes equitable as much as possible. They look at you know sometimes we have you know some a teacher that may have you know 10, 7, but they also may have a physical science which is an introductory class that has larger numbers. So we recognize that, the department recognizes that, all the curriculum coordinators, they look at their departments and they really work hard to be collaborative in that process of making things equitable here. >> Yeah, that's all good. >> And kind of to answer your question, so I was talking about this at work today and before talking about like numbers and the schools and all this stuff and I mean we do have a variety of like income levels in our district, but one one argument for having a really strong school with like strong academics is it pulls families in. Like when we were looking for homes, we literally were looking for an area where we the realtor could say, "Oh, this is a really great school with really awesome teachers and look at what the students are doing." So that's definitely appealing to like bring students in and bring in you know taxpayers and economy and all that good stuff. And then the other thing that I forgot to mention was can do you guys have an ability to recruit your friends into these classes? Is that like not a thing? >> They did. >> Oh, they did. >> They did, yeah. >> Okay, >> [laughter] >> got it. >> Yeah, I I do appreciate the teacher the extra recruitment that that happened cuz like that second push that that is helpful and and I I you know I think this is a good discussion to have because as we're talking about as this district, you know, when when I started on the board when I started on the board 10 years ago, you know, um we were at like 1,600 students in the whole district and we're going to be under 1,000 really soon. So like that's fast and so we you know, we just have to figure out how we can make this work. Um and I'm going to be really happy we've had this discussion. So yeah, go ahead, Pete. >> So as part of I mentioned, you know, long term >> Yeah. >> you know, we I would have liked to be in a different place to have a conversation with you tonight about seven period day because it does it gives us an advisory. It gives us other things. It condenses our classes. It it moves some things around. I have models for that. It's not done. I mean, we're in graduation week and we run out of time and counselors were actually working on Sunday this weekend to try to get that ready and be collaborative and you know, matter of department heads and trying to make that work and try to move forward for next year. They're already looking forward to next year of how to do things. So just being praised like we know the situation is this. This is the low numbers is just because of the students that signed up. This is not like we're looking big picture of how to solve some issues. So even if we talk to seven period day, it's not going to help my numbers right now because those are student sign-ups. But we recognize that moving forward is something that you know, we will fine tune. I just can't fine tune it and have it ready for you at this point this week. >> No, but it's also late in the season to drop a seven period day. So but it that that that's good though. I mean, I'm glad these conversations are starting happening. And also the information that you guys have class that junior the current junior class is one of the smallest classes we have. I think that helps explain some things, too. Um you know, so if that's if that's the case, but I think I am concerned that we would like basically kill our French program if we you know, that that's what the numbers say here if we don't offer French [clears throat] one and French two, then we just won't have French. Cuz I would see I don't see why they would keep going. So, I mean that that one concerns me. Um But, Mr. Golden, any more thoughts? What you'd like to do? Oh, go ahead, Scott. Well, this question for the administration what's what's really our hard deadline to try to figure this out? Yes, ma'am. I mean >> Two weeks ago. >> So, I'm telling you that students already want to know their schedules and so they're anxious going into summer. Mr. Golden here, students have AP work to do over the summer. Um and I don't expect like they they want to know. And I totally understand like I understand the deadline, but really there are deadlines to this. Um we need to get that work done and um they need clear answers. Sorry. >> And don't worry, I'll apologize for >> No, that's a good question. I was looking at the old time, you know, so but Um What I was going to say, you know, I I think some of this is kind of late to be like, "Oh, well, I'll have to retool my entire class for next year like this late in the game." But, you know, it does open conversations for the following year about, you know, talking about combining classes. And I I understand there's different requirements and stuff, but I know other schools combine some classes in other districts. I'm not sure how that is, but I don't know. I don't know. But, I'm wondering have we looked into that? >> So, in your justification pages, the teachers have expressed um that why they can't do that with some of the classes that were suggested. >> Okay. All right. All right. >> I do have a question. Um so, I have fewer issues with I'm going to go to honors physics with running that class because that is kind of one standalone class as we've kind of talked about. Difficult to put an honors track with a regular track. So, it's classes like that that I'm not so worried about. I'm not really worried about ancient world history. Um now, when I start to look at AP European history and we've split it out into two sections, I get a little bit concerned there. Running a section of 10 14 is a great number for that, but a section of 10 and a section of 14 is a little bit Again, a section of four is a little bit difficult. History and film, that's unfortunate. 11 kids is great. Right? It's a great number, but to have to split it into two is tough. Same with intro to philosophy. Uh I will say this, I did talk to the 11th superintendent and she does have some of her language classes staffed. Um so, I think the French one and two, um it would be worthwhile to see if uh the teacher couldn't go back and figure out if there were some way to differentiate that a bit, especially where there are only two students in French two. Um hopefully those are really good dedicated students and they could do some things independently and work on some other things. But, I do think we have to look um very carefully at this and looking at what are some ways to solve, especially when other high schools are able to staff classes like that. I want to thank um Mr. Griffin, who was like, "I absolutely can adapt my classes and work with the percussion kids in some different way." Thank you to him. Thank you to Beth French, who also does that, right? If you look at her classes, she already has staffed classes. She is working on kids independently with different skills at different levels. I want to thank her for that, too. Um otherwise, like I said, I don't have any problem with some of these classes that are running five, six, seven, eight, nine kids um and able to work on that. I think the bigger picture here is that rather than come to this this predicament this late in the season, [clears throat] I think this is really a scheduling issue. I think we really have to look at balancing what did I hear from Storm? AP Chemistry was this year? Or Honors Chemistry, which one? >> Honors Chemistry. >> Honors Chem and then next year you planned on taking Honors Physics. Did I get it right? So it's like things like that that we really need to map out and provide for the kids. So I appreciate that insight and information there. But I do think this is and I'm going to say the hard thing right now. Sometimes you have to get your second choice. Right? Um So 99% getting everything is great. It's not always true life. Sometimes you have to get a second choice, right? My second choice is sitting at home right now on the couch with >> [laughter] >> But I'm here with everybody. So, you know, sometimes that happens so you pick and then you pick an alternative that you can deal with. And maybe that's Do you guys schedule and does it look like period one these classes are offered, period two these classes are offered? Just pick what you want? No, okay. Thank you. No, that's fine. That's all I need to know. The kids gave me the information. Um so like I said, I would advise the board it looks like Python one the class was cut, percussion was taken care of. Honors Physics I would advise the board to go ahead and approve that and move forward. >> That was That was just going to go down the list. >> Go ahead and say what you want. I'm going to take over. >> Oh, no, no. >> Um AP No, Ancient World History seven I think that's great. I like what Mr. Sweetland wrote there. I thought that was a sort of a fun way to you know, add in an extra social studies course. AP European History though, I'm a little bit torn. >> I was going to say here on the size adjustment it says successfully combined in one class. >> Oh, good. >> Is that true? They got that fixed? They got that fixed? >> Perfect. >> All right, well that was good. >> Thank you for reading, Tim. >> Okay. >> Um and film >> I could potentially justify that. Uh intro to philosophy, potentially the two sections there. Once again, I would suggest that French one and two look at getting um stacked. And if I have to form get one of the teachers, maybe Joe with your help from Lebanon to help understand how that looks to run a stacked class, I'm happy to do that. Um French three, seven is to me a good number. Uh Spanish three, shh yes, eight it sounds like a great number. Spanish four, uh those are probably mostly kids that went to the Galapagos. Carly, you taking that? Yeah. Who's taking it? I'll make it. >> He was on the original sign-up. >> Okay, thank you. >> I will confirm he was on the original list of 10 that somehow got to five. I don't know who the class five are. >> Okay. All right. So, you know, Spanish four is Spanish four. It's a little >> Yeah. >> That's nice to be able to offer kids a fourth year of language. So, those are the suggestions that I would propose to the board. >> Okay. Joe, the >> Um so, I So, that was Okay, I'm I'm That was a lot to take in. Just for a second. >> I'm fast like that. >> Um so, honors physics, yes. You're saying honors physics, yes. >> Yep. >> Ancient world history, yes. >> Yep. >> Keep that. >> I would agree. >> Yes. >> Uh European history, yes with one section. >> Yep. >> History and film, no. >> No. >> No. >> I think keep it. >> We can keep it. I mean, the we got the two sections of five and six. >> I'm just yeah, clarifying here. Uh intro to philosophy would be keep if it's one section. It would say that there are two sections. Two students could be potentially lost out of that with one class of 11. >> You recommended sticking to the two sections. >> I think that's the one. I'm a bleeding heart with you. >> Philosophy is a good class, especially like intro to philosophy, honestly. And then I would I would love it. Don't don't tell the booster, but I would love to make that a requirement for everybody, but >> [clears throat] >> Yeah, I think it's at this point, like I said, some of these I think we're stuck with for next year, right? I really do feel like we're kind of stuck with that, but we really need to dig dig into the schedule. We really need to make sure we're we're letting kids know that they may get a second choice, right? Second choices may happen. >> French one and two, as they sit in the schedule, are they back-to-back or are they they're totally separate? Okay, I was looking at that schedule. >> I have something. >> Is this me? >> I have something. Miss Lee is not here, but I have something that nobody else has, and I'll see where they're located. >> Oh, oh, okay. Like in the day, you mean? Okay. Um all right, so that that makes sense. That gives us a bunch of closure, and I agree with you on on those two. Like the the Python, if we can drop that, the percussion, he's taking care of that. Honors physics, keep that. Ancient world history, keep that. One class section of AP Euro, keep the two sections of history and film, keep the two sections of the philosophy, keep Spanish three and four, French three, and then just look to see if we can combine French one and two just because those numbers are pretty low. Um you know, I wonder if you opened up the trip to Montreal to all French students. I hope it would be open to them all. That might entice them to sign up more. >> Tim, I think we did. >> [laughter] >> True, you can't just make French two kids out of thin air. >> I know, but we have the chatter freshmen going. >> Well, I don't Yeah, I don't know. I'm trying to get her friend on the trip. Internationally? >> Sorry. >> And I won't tell you what grade I was in when I went to Quebec City. >> What grade were you in? >> All right. Oh, Scott, go ahead. Sorry. >> Um I just on the French one and two, I mean, I I I skimmed the points made by French teacher. I certainly get that it's far from ideal, but I also the last thing we want to eliminate are the introductory courses for program like that or the whole thing is fall apart. It's like losing your middle school baseball team and or yeah, it's the same same thing. So, I think it's even if it means try to have to justify to the to the public, I think it's really important that we keep that and if it requires combining for one year, it's better than not doing it at all. So, I think it's really important that we maintain that. And those things are going to they're going to they're going to pendulum and bubble anyway. We might have only seven this year, but the could be 15 next year if it goes well or something. >> So, for clarification, are you saying two stands alone or it's combined? >> Well, >> I don't know. >> What are you saying? What are you saying? Keep them alone or keep them >> I believe that two one and two should be combined. >> I think I think making the attempt to combine them with these small numbers is is better I mean it's better than not having any introductory classes. >> At least for one year. I see what you're saying like at least for one year is if we have to combine them. >> Can I allow a student who takes the first classes and understands how French works? >> I'm Coral I said a little bit earlier. I was in a combined French two and three class last year and I was signed up to take French three this year, but it got cancelled because of lack of interest and scheduling issues. Aside from that, and combining language language classes such as that is very beneficial to the kids in like French one in this case, but for me in French two, but it is not very beneficial to the kids in the upper level language class because they are more repeating what they were doing and less learning new information. I understand what you guys are saying for the number sake but even in the class that I was in we had six kids I think. And it was still just so much harder for the upper level kids to learn anything new while the lower level kids were getting a boost in this. >> That's good insight. >> And I do also see that if you guys don't include these classes you might kill your French program cuz the only reason cuz we don't have a French class the French three class this year which is why we don't have a French four class. >> What are you >> That's the issue. >> All right. Thank you for that insight. That helps. >> Can I ask a clarifying question? Yeah, go ahead. >> So you said there's not a French three class here but there's one listed as seven students. >> She said French four French four class for next year. There was not a French three class this year. >> Oh, okay. Thank you. Got it. That's the also Okay, that explains why there's no French four on here. That makes sense. Okay. Yeah, Scott go ahead. >> Just for the record I mean even though it's if if it can be done with the staffing even though it's only two students this year in French two I could get behind keeping them separately for exactly the reasons that you're putting out there. >> Yeah. >> Yeah, it can be justified by saying it's it's the whole program we're dealing with and the fact that we have one class that has a low low student count in this year doesn't mean the whole program. >> Yeah. All right. Anyone else? Dan, did you want to say anything? I didn't mean to put you on the spot. You look like you were about to talk. >> I do. I think we need to get out there and try to boost the foreign language pro- program. I had an opportunity I went to a much larger high school but I took three years of French, three years of Spanish and four years of Latin when I was in high school. Now, we did combine our Latin three and four and it worked spectacularly. You know, the Latin fours helped the Latin threes and um when Latin threes were working individually, the Latin fours got instruction and time with the teacher. And so, it is it is possible and it is possible with upper level students, but it's not easy. I certainly would not suggest that it was easy for my teacher, but you know, go out there and convince students that, you know, learning a foreign language will help them be more well-rounded. Um it's it's a great opportunity. I taught in right on the Canadian border when I first started teaching and so, when I had I had a lot of students whose parents only spoke French. And because I had had French in high school, I could at least communicate with them. And so, there are various opportunities where languages can be and will be used. So, get out there and encourage your classmates to take a foreign language. >> All right. >> So, can I share that our Spanish one numbers are 41 and our Spanish two numbers are 42. >> Okay. >> Excellent. >> So, I mean, that's that's a good testament and I mean, Spanish is is very popular, it's very useful and and French is too, it just doesn't have the same numbers as Spanish. Yes, señorita. >> I I'm Luz Glorich, I teach Spanish here at Moscow High. So, just as we're having this conversation about language and about these class sizes that ebb and flow, you know, it really also goes with their graduating class sizes and the way that those numbers ebb and flow, but also when we get into these upper level language courses, within Sorry, um in my content area and in French, you know, they're one-offs. You know, it's hard a lot of times, like we're talking about kids getting their places, but these kids are dedicating three, four years to these language areas and they're making so many strides that we want to see them continue to have those opportunities. And, you know, unfortunately, it's not always an issue of marketing these courses. You know, we had 21 students in Spanish three this year. We had 21 students in and Spanish four. First year that I taught here in six years, we got two sections of Spanish four, which was pretty incredible. And I think, you know, when we have these smaller class sizes, as we see, as we've seen with not having French four next year, that has a direct effect on not being able to continue to have these upper level courses. And so, I think that's just something important to consider. Yes, we need to be marketing these courses and having these students convince their friends to stay in these courses, but this is not an every year thing that all of these things tend to happen specifically in this content area. >> I'm so glad you said that. So, what I know that you are a Spanish teacher, but what would it mean for a French teacher to combine curriculum for French one and French two in your opinion as a foreign language teacher because I'm guessing that they're very different. And also, I think like what could you like lose out on if you had to combine those classes? >> I think especially with French So, a little bit of background about myself, I am also a French speaker. So, I do have some insight in terms of language itself as well. French as a language is written very linguistically differently than Spanish. Spanish, you can pretty much look at it and you know how it's pronounced. It's written very much like it's pronounced. French it's not that way. Um I took French one when I was a senior in high school and then went on to take French in college and having that deficit, I was in a class with upper-level students who knew far more than I did because I happened to place into it understanding the mechanics of the language and that put me at a deficit to those days where, you know, our French teacher may be teaching to the upper-level students. I think that um you know, it would be a disadvantage for French one students who are still trying to get a grasp on the language. You have to memorize how everything is pronounced in French. It's much like English where they have some words that we don't quite follow the pronunciation rules even though they say we have these rules. Um and I think to Coral's point as well, you know, I've worked in the years past to try to find some creative solutions for students to continue taking upper-level classes where they didn't fit into their class levels and so they would interact with those um languages and they don't get the same thing out of the course as they would in a traditional course where the teacher is able to spend all of their time and their energy focusing on that specific course content um for those students. I hope that kind of answers your question. >> All right. >> Thank you. >> Cool. Thank you. So, questions. Um okay. So, where are we at everybody? So, basically I think we're down to just French one two. Honestly, I think we're fine on the other ones. Um and I mean it's a compelling it's a compelling argument and and I don't want to shoot ourselves in the foot on our French program. Um do I think they can combine them? Maybe. I think other schools combine them and I think that it's possible to craft it and in the future is that what we might have to look at like going down the road but we might have to look at that. Um yeah. Any other thoughts from anybody? >> Scott, go. >> You know, to that what you just said, I I think it's fair to give it a year, keep them both separate. If it continues to be an issue, then we, you know, need to look at solutions, but I'm willing to give it a try. I'm taking one step at a time anyway. >> That's fair. >> Larry? >> I agree. >> Okay. >> All right. >> Dan, you're nodding your head. All right, Jim, what do you think? >> Let me put you on the spot. >> [laughter] >> Put me on the spot. >> No, we're just taking a straw poll. >> Can I offer if for some reason that's one of those two students moves out, then we no longer hold the class. Is that fair? >> Well, so yeah, I have a real issue with a one to two ratio in language class. I just I have that issue from an aspect of utilizing our resources as a district. But I totally understand yes, if a kid was to move out of that, then we would not run French two. Is basically what it would be. Right? So, um, or we would run the combined class. Excuse me, not just run French two. Let me correct myself on that. So, um, but yeah, it's it's hard for me to justify two kids in a class. It really is. >> Thank you. >> Did you want to add anything? >> We can what will happen with this is if you decide it has to be a stacked class, I have to then get the teacher support. >> Mhm. >> That will be the situation there. I I don't necessarily know what that process looks like after. >> That's fair. >> I just want the board to realize >> ma'am. >> So, I I just want the board to realize that we probably won't magically create French three students the following year. >> That's what my next point is. >> And then French four students the following year. >> Right. >> So, at some point we might have to tell these kids you've taken two years of French, sorry, if we can't stack it, you know, then then you've ended it. And I know But not what colleges want to see. >> No. >> They want to see four years of a language. So I'm just cautioning the school board that if you're allowing for this class to go forward with the section of only two on staff, at some point you're either going to have to stack it or eliminate it, and that to me is more detrimental to those two students to do that later on. >> I see. >> [sighs] >> All right. That's a lot to take in. I get it. I get it. Well, does anyone want to make a motion, I think? I'll make a motion. Okay. Um so should I list the classes out to accept and which ones to decline? Um what should we do here? For the motion. Make >> Approve classes that the school board approves with a number under 10. >> All right. So I'll make a motion that we approve uh percussion with a class size or no, for for honors physics class size of five um ancient world history class of seven uh AP European history um class size of 14, is that correct? >> Four and 10. >> With a combination class of 14 as a solution? >> That's correct. That That class is going to be divided into one section. >> Okay. That That's going to be about one section. Okay. Okay. Um history and film with two sections uh intro to philosophy with two sections >> Mhm. >> um a combination of French one and French two with seven students French three with seven students Spanish three with eight students and Spanish four with five students. >> Okay. All right. So anyone second on that? >> I'll second. >> Okay. Thanks. All right. Further discussion on this. Uh all right. So that is with a combined an attempt at least to combine French one and two um to try to try and do that, I think. Period. That's what we're directing the school to do. In this motion. All right. Any further discussion? Yes, Scott. >> Can I offer an amendment amendment to the motion um to keep French one French two separate for this year and revisit next year? Or I guess I'm asking you Can you clarify why you think it would be a greater issue if we end up having to um do this it next year and combine versus this year? >> Cuz next year they would be in French three right? And they would I would assume combine with a handful of the students from French who are currently taking French who would currently take French three next year. Seven, but I would imagine that those would dip down to six or something or five. >> Yeah, I don't know if it's better to combine them at the lower level um you know where the French one students would really benefit from some French two information or if you try to combine grade because they'll be French three. So do you combine them with the two students the French two students or the French four students? Like I I don't know where the best combination happens. I just know that combination will have to happen. >> And and I guess maybe to amend your amendment is or maybe the other thing we that I don't know I don't know I don't know but maybe the thing that that we do is figure out is it better to put the French two students with the three or the one? And that might be up to the teacher is which one works better. Because it might be better for students those two students to go with the three. And and piggyback off them. >> I think also I'm kind of given So I'm looking at the comments from the French teacher right now and as she says the dedicated self-selected groups in advanced level languages demonstrate commitment to asking and surprising and passion for learning and clarity of purpose. So um my thought process would be to go with the lower level classes to combine because um at least and I'm I'm I'm kind of a foundations teacher in general is um it it making sure that those foundations are sound I think would be more appropriate in that aspect I think. I think that's what I'm trying to say. >> Mhm. >> I agree Joe and I I think Coral said it very well. She said that being a French one student with well what were you Coral? French one or French two or French three? French three. She really benefited from that. So I have seven five kids that it really would benefit you know from that. >> Mhm. >> I don't know Chris. >> Yes sir. >> I really would be worried that if we got rid of French one French two we'd be losing tons of foundations and then we wouldn't have a strong like upper class for French. I just like I'm not a French teacher but I can't imagine that you wouldn't lose out and then your French three and French four students would just be at a lower level. >> Mhm. That's right. >> Yes Yeah so I I'd like to go ahead and move an amendment to the motion to keep French one and French two separate. >> Okay. >> And we'll see where that leads. >> Joe, do you would you like to change your motion or you want to uh stick with your original motion? >> I'll stick with my original motion. >> Okay. All right. So we have his original motion on the floor uh and now you have made an amendment to it to split them into two separate ones. Is there a second to that amendment? >> I'll second it. >> Diane will second that amendment. All right. So now we're going to vote on the amendment to Joe's motion which would be to approve basically all the classes as discussed with the separate French one and French two. Right? >> [clears throat] >> Everybody clear? >> Wait, what are we voting on? >> We're voting on So I say So Joe made an amendment to basically to approve what's on this list but with the combined French one and 2. And then Scott made an amendment and then >> To separate them. >> To separate French 1 and 2. >> Joseph Joe made the motion. >> Yes, the original motion. We made the Yes. >> Don't we have to vote on the original motion first? >> No, because we're making an amendment to the motion. >> did Joe say no? >> He said no, but he does not have to accept it. >> to accept it. accept it, but I am accepting >> Yeah. >> It was seconded by the amendment was seconded by the amendment to the motion. >> just voting on the right to put the amendment on the motion or is this a whole new motion now? >> We are now voting on the amendment, Scott's amendment. >> Scott's amendment. >> Okay. >> Which is And then after this we will see what we will see what the original motion amended >> voting on the amendment. >> We've just voted on the amendment. Thank you. Thank you for clarifying. You guys have earned your treat. This is the most complex meeting we've had in years. >> I know. Welcome. >> All right. So right now we are voting on the amendment to separate them out. All right. Do you want to do a roll call or do you want to see how this sounds on the mics? Let's see how this sounds on the roll call. All right, we'll do a roll call. Roll call. All right, Dan. >> Yes. >> Uh Tim. Uh yes. Joe. >> No. >> All right, Scott. >> Yes. >> And Laura? >> Yes. >> Okay. So we've amended it to separate the classes. All right. So now the motion on the floor is to accept the list which is basically everything that we just talked about. And I know Pamela had it voted down correctly. >> Got it. >> I know. Of course you did. All right. Any further discussion on anything else through here? Anything else for first class sizes? If anything I think this got our conversation kickstarted for next year. >> Well, I'm going to ask a question in a minute. Yeah. >> You're going to ask a question in a minute? Okay. Would you want to ask a question before we vote on this? >> No, you do this. This is good. >> [laughter] >> Robert's Rules of Order and our students are learning all about >> That's right. That's right. It is Robert's Rules of Order. Every second and fourth Friday come on down for Robert's Rules of Order. It's great. Uh all right. So we're going to vote now. Okay, we're voting on the motion, the main motion to approve them all with freshman one and two. Basically everything on this list is gray except for percussion and pipe on and then with the combined AP Euro and then the separate sections of film and philosophy. All right? All right. Do roll call. Pam? >> Yes. >> Tim? Yes. Joe? >> Yes. >> Scott? >> Yes. >> Laura? >> Yes. >> All right. So that passes. So there you go. You're all set. Thank you for your efforts. See you guys. And we got more meetings so I know you guys are busy little chopping but just stay around on this June night. >> I just want to thank the students and the parents that came that takes this very seriously and appreciate the staff members coming to also answer questions and as we went along. So I really want to applaud that. >> Mhm. >> I have Can I ask something for the next meeting? >> Sure. You're on. >> On the 23rd. >> That's our retreat. So we're not doing too much of meeting stuff but >> Well, so I'm going to ask what is part of our really looking at for next year is for engagement. We have our whole bunch of things but I would like to bring forward an amendment to our student handbook addressing an exact amount of unexcused absences um with very clear uh procedures related to that. So it's a procedure not a policy but you have approved my student handbook and I would need to do that amendment before it goes to our students. >> That's fair. That good? All right. Good. Glad to hear this year not next year not this year. >> [laughter] >> All right. That sounds good, Tim. All right. We can And we can talk about that at the Yeah, cuz I want to get a kick start on it. >> Yeah, we can add that to We'll have a small agenda. >> agenda. >> You know, we'll just look at approving that. >> Yeah. Yeah, that sounds fine. Cuz the other thing uh while I have you in front of me, we need to have him bring the New York trip for music to approve fundraising for it. I don't think he's done it yet. >> Oh. >> Okay. Um but all right. Okay. >> Tim, can I give you something? >> More presents for us, please. >> is um based on your request for the AP. >> Oh yeah. We had the we >> I didn't put it on the agenda but I want to share [snorts] that with >> If you have it already then >> I do. I have want to share that with >> That was a question that came up from the board like how many students take AP classes versus how many take the actual exam. So now all of them says plumbing but like I know that like when Lydia took it she was the only one who took the AP English a lot of kids take AP English but I think she was the only one who took the exam and you know it happens like that happens. So we were just curious how many kids are doing the whole thing and now that we know they all do it. It's great. Mhm. All right. Awesome. >> Woohoo. >> Mhm. Cool. This is great. And I like how you included ones that we uh there we don't offer but kids are picking up because that might show us what's what classes would be popular in the future, right? All right. Cool. All right. All right. Yes. I'm going to check. Yeah. Oh yeah, I guess we should get back to the agenda. Um now that we're done with all that stuff. So thank you students. Like I mean we're we're not going to talk about classes anymore but see you all but you know what it's a nice community. So >> Can I say one thing? >> Yeah, you can sit over there. >> You guys like had a big win tonight but recruit. Talk to your friends. Talk you know encourage your families to you know talk about the budget and the voting and filling up these class sizes. This is how we make our school strong. Talk to your friends. Talk to your family. Talk to your neighbors. >> Yeah. And and and seriously we have public comment at every school board meeting so and and so it doesn't just take your student rep but if you have anything on your mind tell your peers like come on down to a school board meeting. I'd love to have you guys speaking here and just telling us what's on your mind cuz we really do. We're like we live here. We're parents. We're had kids in the district and we know I can't say we know how it is every day with what you go through but we'd love to hear from you. So please please do that. So cool. Thank you guys. >> I just want to say you guys are the school. Yeah. Okay. So you really have to advocate sometimes for yourself and if we don't know it or we're unsure, we need to hear from you because you are the school. >> [clears throat] >> All right. Cool. All right, let's get back to agenda. Um next thing we have Do we Do we have any more updates on the wellness initiative? Or not yet? Table this. >> I do not have any updates on it. >> Okay. All right, we'll table that until the next one. All right. So, next on our agenda we have the low salt no salt zone request and you see in your packet um Let's see. So, you see in your packet, this is some really cool stuff. So, we met with the Friends of Cayuga Street Lake and they came and presented to us and you'll see um they've been tracking So, they through volunteers and this is a really cool thing and I would love to get them into our biology classes. So, they're volunteers that go out and measure different chemicals in the water at the outlets. And so, they talk about chloride values, talk about sulfates. So, chloride especially has been shooting up in Cayuga Street Lake. And one big thing you can do to reduce that is watch your road salt when you're getting, you know, salt on the roads. And so, they looked here and you can see on What is this? The third second page, um you see a map, a Google Sky View, a Google map here. Um and you see Cayuga Street here, you see Roberts Road down at the end which is kind of where the um the meeting house is and then Old North Church is like where you turn off to go to um Powder Magazine School. And all those yellow dots there are wells that have really high salt content. And so, like so much that the person's like, "Oh, this is not good. I'm going to get this tested." So, tested sure enough they're through the roof with salt. And then you see down at the bottom, the last page, there's a little map, bigger map. Um so, this shows you where the salt contaminated salt contaminated wells are. You have the red dot which is the end of their zone that they would like. And so, there's three little green dots on there as well um showing where they would like to propose to will stop or reduce salting in the wintertime. Um Um, they have other chemicals or other things they can treat the roads with now. Um, and since it's a from what I understand is a state state maintained road, so state DOT is the one that puts this out, which is why we have to go through this process. Um, so in order for the Canice Friends Canice Street Lake to get lower salt on the road, they have to talk to the town the town the town DPW Department of Public Works, the Police Department, the Fire Department, the School District because our buses are going on those roads. And so they need to make sure that there's enough salt. Like if you if like let's say it was like a hill or on a curve or they'd say we want to get rid of salt on there. We'd be like, "No, that's crazy. You have school buses that go there." So, they wanted to bring this to us and luckily Sierra from Butler was there at the meeting. And um, she gave her blessing to this because we looked at where the road kind of goes up and is before where it says Pinnacle and it's before uh, 358 Canice Street. So, the road doesn't go up and curve. It's pretty flat from the that stretch around curve. Um, and you know, in talking to Butler's they said that's fine. Um, and the other thing is that the state DOT will determine what is low salt and what is no salt. So, they may do some low salt farther away from the lake and they may do no salt next to the lake. They you know, so they're the ones who make that final determination. But it's it's really just a request from the Friends of the Lake through the town. So, that is the um, in a nutshell the low no salt zone request. Any questions on that? >> Yeah, did they have any like data to back up the safety on the roads >> Um, this is um, they don't have any data to like to to back up for like I'm not sure what you would have for like your data. But like I guess like is there more crashes? Like you know what I mean? >> like accidents and um, also like what's the what they do sand instead or >> Yeah, it's it's usually like a heavy sand and there is some snow melt something in there. Um, I don't remember what it was. Um, but you can I mean this definitely has a lot of salt on that road. >> And I think they might need to put up a signs, too, cuz like people traveling locally, if they all of a sudden their roads are not salted, they probably know about that. >> I believe that that's the case. >> Yeah. They noted as no salted road. >> Cuz I think if you go towards Hanover, there's some sections in Hanover that have low no salt zones. That I've I've seen those signs. Cuz cuz you do get a you do get a warning when you're driving through. Um, but like like I said, I think our main concern that section of Kane Street is really long and flat and wide. So, the bus didn't have any concern with like sliding off the road or curves or anything like that. So, that's that's what they said. So. Anything to add to that, Mr. Knight? Did I miss anything? >> No, nothing. >> I do think you said to him, though, that even if we give permission, the state may determine it's not safe >> Right. >> to go down to low salt or no salt in that area. So, it's not our final determination. It's just us saying that we understand that the bus company is well aware that there will be no salt on that section of the road, and they are in agreement with it being okay for buses to travel. >> Yeah. There could be no salt. It doesn't even mean that there will Yeah. And they may look at this and say, "You know what? We'll do low salt on the whole thing just because of the concerns and stuff." But, no, it's a good it's a good question, though. Um, but >> Yeah, well, I think the DOT, as a matter of course, will put signage to that effect. >> Yeah, I just Sorry. It would just be really horrible if one of our buses went off the >> Yeah, I agree. I agree. >> That could be too deadly. >> I agree, but I I think we probably have a higher rate of buses going off the road in Orange. >> I think it's great. >> [laughter] >> No offense to anybody in Orange today. No, I'm just being I'm talking topography with the way that hills go in the ice. >> Actually, in all in all seriousness, when I speak about it, Orange we do not use salt. >> Okay. >> It's it's it's ineffective on gravel roads, anyway. And so we always use sand and it was always gravel. Yeah, we had lots of problems with buses. Our roads are up and over the mountains and you know, it's pretty so you know, we did the best we could. Having low or no salt on Canning Street where it's flat and wide, I just don't see that as being an issue. >> I just wanted to add to is she said that they said that this was like a repeated problem. You know, they get their wells back to normal and then you know, following season again and it's not you know, it's costly for them. You know, in order to >> So it's a direct relationship on a seasonal level. >> Yes. >> When it comes to that. Okay. >> Yeah, it's not like it's just contaminated once and then it's done. They get it remediated. They have to get like empty saline and then like 2 years later it's back to being salty, you know, so. >> [clears throat] >> Any other discussion on this? I will make a motion to approve the low no salt zone request as presented. >> I'll second. >> All right, it's got a second. Any further discussion? All right, since this is not as important, I think we can just do a regular vote. All those in favor signify by saying I. All opposed? Abstentions? All right, next the accreditation capital reserve transfer request. This is to move money from our capital reserve account that we sock away so that we can get accredited for this school. So seeing as how we just went through the NEASC accreditation, Michelle has a request here to transfer $6,153.67 for the NEASC representative stipends and supplies from the accreditation capital reserve fund. So I will go ahead and make that motion to transfer that amount. >> I'll second. >> All right, then second. Any discussion on this? This is a formality of moving money from one to the other. All right, all those in favor signify by saying I. I. All opposed. Abstentions. All right. Up next is re-approve request to school board approval of the transfer from our facilities capital reserve fund an amount of $189,747.93 for the football and field hockey field renovations as are currently undergoing going underway. Um we added this to our capital reserve plan last year and so it is all accounted for there or so. I will make a motion that we approve transfer of $189,747.93 to the for the football and field hockey field renovations from the facilities capital reserve fund. Do we have a second? >> I'll second. >> All right. Joe second. Any discussion on this? All right. Seeing none, all those in favor signify by saying I. I. All opposed. Abstentions. All right. Next on our agenda it is the encumbrance list. So these are things that we are going to use from the unencumbered fund balances to um finish off some things that we were trying to do throughout the year and just couldn't quite get to. So um you'll see the encumbrance I'll just go down the list and Michelle if you have any questions we'll shout out to you. Um so this one first one is a passenger minivan and that was requested by the SAU. And Amita, do you want to just detail why that one is specifically different than the other vans we have? >> Yes. So this van the other vans that we have are not allowed to be called mixed use school buses which means we cannot transport kids to or from school to home. So what we would need to have is a smaller van which is a regular minivan if you will um and we can then have our licensed bus drivers or van drivers that are licensed and rostered with the state of New Hampshire along with adding lights to the top which not their bus has donated and outfitting it and getting it inspected as a mixed-use school bus. Um this will allow us to transport kids, if you know, need be to or from school to home. >> And the difference is that, like you said, the passenger vans that we have up there, those are used for like team travel, those are used for academic travel, but they are not used to take students to and from home. They are like transport students while they are with us during the day. Is that correct? >> Yeah, they're too big. >> Yeah, they're they're and they're too big. Yeah, yeah. All right, so that's that. Any questions on what that minivan is and how that's different? We did just get a minivan, but that's a handicap minivan, correct? >> Correct. And that is actually >> That is what it looked like, right? >> inspected, and we are able to use that as a mixed-use school bus. >> So, we would get another one of those, but non-handicap, so you actually fit more kids in >> Correct. >> Okay, got it. All right. Um the next one is Foundations uh for EVE EVS EES IRS fourth and fifth grade aid. What is that? You know what Foundations are? >> Yeah, so Foundations um is there is a new piece of legislature out there that states that uh all kids in fourth grade now must have phonics. >> Oh, so you're saying they must have phonics? >> So, they now um phonics education So, what we teach in through grade is uh the Foundations program. So, this is an expansion of that um program. We did not budget for this, so but we do need it to meet this um unfunded mandate. >> To meet the unfunded mandate from the state. Yeah, I I see that. I like these mics. Thank you. To make my point. All right, now that's good. That that helps a lot. Um I know some of the other ones. So, gym doors here at the high school, um are those Which ones are those? The internal ones? Um facing one of the hallways? Do you agree? >> Correct. >> Okay, all right, that's I'm not Yeah, we don't have external ones. What am I talking about? Um Chromebooks, I believe Craig talked about this when he here last. Um more Chromebooks, so that was there. Arts and Letters, um CES EVS additional amount for revised quote. Is this This is Arts and Letters, one of our curriculum programs, and the cost went up or we had more students order books. >> Um so, there was a discrepancy in the um amount that we were quoted this fall when we were budgeting. And it was quite a large discrepancy. And um April Yeah, April April went back and said, "Whoa, whoa, whoa." And so, they did cut it uh down to the 26, which you will see. >> Okay. Good deal. All right. And then um >> Can I ask a question? >> Oh, yeah. Go ahead. Go. So, this is something that was that was revised quote by the um supplier. Is that correct? So, this is something that we committed to and then the supplier changed it. Is that right? >> Uh that is my understanding of it for some reason. I don't know if the representative swapped or >> [clears throat] >> what what it was, but this is truly for the teachers' kids and some of the, you know, bundles of books. I forget what they were called. Um but for those reading libraries from the classrooms. >> Yeah. We did like Arts and Letters, so that's good. I did like Arts and Letters. Um next one or two things in here, the house lights um in the auditorium, which if you've been in there, some of them are on their last legs. It is a 10-year-old auditorium now. Those do a lot of work. Um and as we decided a while ago that part of the CIP or part of the CIP process, we would want to include stuff in the auditorium so that it didn't just fall apart. We invest a lot of money in this. Let's keep it nice. Um and the other thing is six stage lights um replacing those, so that seems pretty standard. And then the CES gym renovation, we have talked about this a few times, um removing the stage at CES and turning that into some storage so that we can move all the uh cafeteria tables in there, give the um PE teacher some space as well for an office, and really make that um gymnasium more accessible and more usable a lot more times. Like youth sports leagues could have practices in there and other stuff could happen in there that we just can't do right now because there's cafeteria table all over the place. All right. Anything else? Did I miss anything on that one? All right. Any questions on any of these encumbrances? All right. I will make a motion to approve the encumbrances list as presented in the amount of $259,286. Do I have a second? >> I'll I'll second. >> All right, it's got a second. Any further discussion? All right. All those in favor signify by saying aye. >> Aye. >> All opposed? No abstentions. All right. Up next, plowing and mowing bids. So you see here we put out solicitations to we sent out inquiries to five different places and we received bids from two different ones for a three-year bid. And the recommendation here we have budgeted $108,000 for the year. Um the recommended bid is going to MTD in the three-year bid amount of $268,968. $268,968 with year one being $89,656, year two $89,656, and year three $89,656. So if anything it keeps our budgeting very very flexible. So I I like that and that is a good recommendation. So and I'm going to let Mike make the motion. >> I'll make a motion to accept the bid for total three-year bid for 260 68,000? >> Yep. >> 68 968. >> 968 to MTD Property Management. >> Okay. >> And they are our current supplier our current contractor. >> That's right. >> And and you've been happy with them Amanda? And she's not here anymore but >> Uh they have been responsive to requests or issues. >> Yes. >> All right. Okay. All right. Any other comments on this one? All right. Okay. Yeah, we need a second. All right, it's got a second. Okay. All right, all those in favor of approving the following and mowing bids to MTD signify by saying I. All opposed, abstentions. All right, now this is Amanda's favorite time of year. I'm going to make a motion that we grant superintendent the authority the authority to hire New Hampshire certified budgeted positions from tomorrow, June 10th, through the summer months because we need her to be able to do that and she with the understanding that you'll bring that to the board's next meeting, but this allows you to make the offer. >> Tim, could you also add to that the ability to accept resignations? >> Oh, sure. And I will add that to accept resignations as well. All right, and would anyone like to second? >> I'll second. >> All right, whoever came out of it first can second. All right, any questions on this? I know some of you are newer to the board, but this is basically something that you you know, we only have we have our our retreat in June, we have one meeting in July and then you know, we have two meetings in August, but this allows you to be able to hire somebody immediately, make an offer if you need be, especially in this time right now between now and the end of July. Yeah, so it it allows her to make the offer, sign the contract and then you bring it to us at the next meeting and as a you know, to remind us what's going on. All right, any other discussion? All right, all those in favor of approval of the authority to hire for the summer signify by saying I. All opposed, abstentions. All right, so there are two updates in your packet here as well. One is our proficiency scores for the 25-26 school year. So, you can talk about you can look here at grades 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and then the uh uh 11th grade as well. So, you see some really good at state proficiency gains, which is great. A few that are under and then a few that need some more work. So, uh there's nothing we need to do on this. It's just really informational, right? >> No, and more information will come out at the EIC meeting on Thursday. I do just want to point out I have a the annual report out looking at 24-25 scores. Just uh want to recognize that in fifth grade uh we had red in math were moved to yellow, which is a 3 to 6% difference. So, we're just slightly behind. Um the fifth grade, I'm very pleased to say, is now proficient. >> Wonderful. >> Meets the state average for science. >> Wonderful. >> Yeah, so very good for there. Um Ch- other changes that are noteworthy, I would like to note that the seventh grade in their math proficiency is uh once again in the yellow range, so that's 3 to 3 to 6% below. Eighth grade, I'm very pleased to say, is now fully at or above in all topics. >> Mhm. >> Well, not science. >> Look at their science. >> Science, they moved up to um 3 to 6. They moved to yellow. So, we [clears throat] will have that. And the other scores are uh not in yet. So, we don't have um the high school SAT scores. >> All right. SAT scores. >> Oh, that's just SAT scores. >> Okay. All right. Any questions from Anna? Thank you for sharing this. This is very helpful. Uh it's a good data point to hold up and then put in the annual report. >> Well, I think it's even more important to note the growth over the last 3 years. >> Yeah. >> Specifically, is that there has been continued growth in this district uh for year after year after year. And that is a testament to what our teachers are doing in the classroom and giving them and the administrators space in order to do that. So, I want to make that known because it is very hard to repeat that year after year after year if you are not um giving the support that you need. >> Thank you, Joe. >> Would it help if when we're presenting this to the public um to have like a graph showing the growth or the levels of the I don't know. >> I think so. April's got more data. If you look at that you'll see a lot more in >> Okay. And on that note was UIC next week? >> That would be this week. >> No, it I >> Then wait, isn't it No, it's next week, right? >> It is because we're like let's not do it the day before graduation. I think that's what we decided it was going to >> right. You're right. It is next week. >> So, all right. >> Thank you. >> Okay. All right. So, that's proficiency and then graduation percentage. >> 100%. >> All right, there you go. Thank you. >> Woo! >> All right. >> Yeah. >> Okay. Um agenda items for the next meeting. So, as a reminder the next meeting will be two Tuesdays from now. The fourth Tuesday will be our retreat. We're going to dress a little different. So, we'll have a very small regular board meeting at the beginning to just take care of any business that we need. Um but the rest of it will be our retreat where we focus on our goals for the year. We are going to meet down in the community room. Is that correct? I believe that. >> Correct. >> We'll order some pizzas, so watch for your If anyone has any requests, but we'll get a couple pizzas. Why not? >> Correct. >> Okay. I mean you should get food for this, so why not, right? Pizza sounds delicious, so. Um but yeah, that's the next meeting. So, all right. Public comment. If you want to have any more You want to make any more comments? >> Sure. >> We We are legally mandated by the state to have 30 minutes of public comment if people want to speak. This towns don't have to have that, but schools do, so. All right. Well, thank you, Mr. Chairman. Um personnel, resignations and nominations. So, you have your green sheet here, which has a lot of retirements and resignations. So, I will make a motion that we accept the um staff nominations and the resignations and retirement and then and as presented here. And on the retirements I want to add except with many thanks. >> Uh second. >> Okay. All right. Any discussion on these? All right. All those in favor signify by saying aye. Aye. All opposed? Abstentions? All right. Up next, we have public We have a non-public section session in accordance with RSA 91-A, column 3, row number 2, subset B for tuition student requests and anything else besides that? >> Uh B, hiring. >> Okay. >> B, hiring and K, tuition uh contract. >> Okay. All right. So, we're going to I make a motion that we go to non-public. Do I have a second? >> Um second. >> All right. Laura seconds. Now, we have to do a roll call for it. Dan? >> Yes. >> Tim? Yes. >> Joe? >> Yes. >> Scott? >> Yes. >> Laura? >> Yes. >> All right. We're in non-public. Thank you, everybody, for coming. >> Chairman.